Like my football analysis, my positions on these amendments are my opinions, and should be taken as such.
Amendment 1 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, relating to the
Forever Wild Land Trust, to reauthorize the trust for a 20-year period.
(Proposed by Act No. 2011-315)
I am actually sort of torn on this one. The Forever Wild Land Trust sets aside 10% of the interest earned by the Alabama Trust Fund for purchasing land for public hunting and recreational use. The Alabama Trust Fund is money that comes to the state from oil and gas leases in the Gulf of Mexico. The FWLT was created in 1992 and has set aside 227,000 acres for public use so far. The fiscal conservative in me says that setting aside money for 20 years may be foolish and wasteful (one proposal was to shorten this to a five-year renewal, but it failed in the legislature), but I like the idea of using the money for something related to the environment as sort of a trade off for the oil and gas origins of the money. Alfa is against it, and that actually tips me over in favor of it. I am leaning toward YES.
Amendment 2 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, as amended, to
allow issuance by the State from time to time of general obligation
bonds under the authority of Section 219.04 and Section 219.041 to the
Constitution of Alabama of 1901, as amended, so long as the aggregate
principal amount of all such general obligation bonds at any time
outstanding is not in excess of $750 million. This amendment would
replace the maximum aggregate principal limitations currently contained
in said Sections 219.04 and 219.041. The proposed amendment would also
allow issuance by the State of general obligation refunding bonds under
the authority of Sections 219.04 and 219.041 to the Constitution of
Alabama of 1901, as amended, subject to certain minimum savings
thresholds and limitations of maximum average maturity. (Proposed by Act
No. 2012-567)
This does two things - allows the state to refinance loans at a lower rate, which makes sense, and allows the state to issue bonds to raise money to lure businesses to Alabama. From a strictly conservative standpoint, I can see both sides of this argument, but if you look at companies, like Mercedes and ThyssenKrupp, who have received incentives to locate in the state, it's hard to argue that that is anything but good for Alabama. I'm voting YES.
Amendment 3 - Relating
to Baldwin County, proposing an amendment to the Constitution of
Alabama of 1901, to define the Stockton Landmark District within the
county and to prohibit the annexation by local law of any property
within the district into any municipality. (Proposed by Act No.
2011-316)
This prevents a larger city from annexing the community of Stockton without a vote of the people there. This is one of those dumb amendments that has to be voted on statewide even though it only affects one county. However, I think that in principle the residents of a community should have a say in their own annexation. I am voting YES.
Amendment 4 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, to repeal portions
of Amendment 111, now appearing as Section 256 of the Official
Recompilation of the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, as amended,
relating to separation of schools by race and to repeal Section 259,
Amendment 90, and Amendment 109, relating to the poll tax.(Proposed by
Act No. 2011-353)
The purpose of this amendment is to remove racist language from the Alabama constitution. I have heard several ads about how this amendment is going to remove the right for public schools in Alabama, and while my kids are home-schooled, and that would not affect my children, the prospect that public schools will be eliminated is preposterous. This amendment failed to pass by a 50-49% vote in 2004, I believe, and the national reporting was about how backwards Alabama decided to keep Jim Crow language in the constitution. Let's not do that again, okay guys? Also, AEA is against it, which nearly always puts me on the opposite side. Vote YES.
A quick note here: my beef with Alfa and AEA is not their members or even their stances, per se. It is the enormous amount of influence that they and their lobbyists wield in Montgomery. In my opinion, the power that they have in Alabama is unhealthy because there is no balance against it, so I generally vote against them in principle.
Amendment 5 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, to provide for the
transfer of the assets and liabilities of the Water Works and Sewer
Board of the City of Prichard to the Board of Water and Sewer
Commissioners of the City of Mobile, presently known as the Mobile Area
Water and Sewer System. (Proposed by Act No. 2011-543)
This is a friendly transfer of the water works from Prichard to Mobile. Vote YES.
Amendment 6 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, to prohibit any
person, employer, or health care provider from being compelled to
participate in any health care system. (Proposed by Act No. 2011-617)
This would theoretically allow Alabama residents to opt out of Obamacare. I'm not sure if it would stand up in court and certainly if Obama is re-elected, it will be challenged if passed. However, I am fundamentally opposed to government-mandated and controlled health care and I will vote YES.
Amendment 7 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, to amend Amendment
579 to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, now appearing as Section
177 of the Official Recompilation of the Constitution of Alabama of
1901, as amended, to provide that the right of individuals to vote for
public office, public votes on referenda, or votes of employee
representation by secret ballot is fundamental. (Proposed by Act No.
2011-656)
This would require that public elections and private union votes are taken by secret ballot. The AFL-CIO opposes this, for obvious reasons. I'm voting YES.
Amendment 8 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, to repeal the
existing provisions for legislative compensation and expenses and
establish the basic compensation of the Legislature at the median
household income in Alabama; to require legislators to submit signed
vouchers for reimbursement for expenses; and to prohibit the Legislature
from increasing the compensation or expenses payable to its members.
(Proposed by Act No. 2012-269)
Basically this repeals a recently-passed pay raise for Alabama legislators and ties their income to the median household income in Alabama, which means that when the citizens are doing well, the legislators will be paid well. This seems like a common sense idea to me, and would incentify legislators to improve the income of Alabama households. I'm voting YES.
Amendment 9 - Proposing
an amendment to the private corporation provisions of Article 12 of the
Constitution of Alabama of 1901, to become effective January 1, 2014,
to continue the authority of the Legislature to pass general laws
pertaining to corporations and other entities; to continue the authority
of the Legislature to regulate and impose a business privilege tax on
corporations and other entities; and to repeal various provisions
concerning private corporations, railroads, and canals. (Proposed by Act
No. 2012-275)
The Alabama GOP site says this removes outdated language, which seems fine, but that makes me wonder why that's important enough to create an amendment to do. Among other things, it seems to strike a provision explicitly protecting churches and religious organizations from privilege taxes. I am voting NO.
Amendment 10 - Proposing
an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, effective January
1, 2014, to amend Section 247 relating to the authority of the
Legislature concerning banks and banking, to repeal various other
provisions of Article XIII concerning banks and banking; and to repeal
Amendment 154 to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, now appearing as
Section 255.01 of the Official Recompilation of the Constitution of
Alabama of 1901, as amended, subject to the contingency that a new
Article XII of the state constitution is adopted that repeals existing
Section 232 of the state constitution, and subject to the contingency
that Sections 10A-2-15.01 and 10A-2-15.02, Code of Alabama 1975, are
repealed. (Proposed by Act No. 2012-276)
This also appears to be removing outdated banking language, some of which is invalidated by the current Federal monetary system. Among other things, it strikes language about having a gold standard. Again my question is, "why is this important now?" Some sources I have read say that the intent is to allow state and local investment in public corporations, which is currently prohibited. In any event, it seems sketchy to me. When in doubt, vote NO.
Amendment 11 - Relating to Lawrence County, proposing an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, to prohibit any municipality located
entirely outside of Lawrence County from imposing any municipal
ordinance or regulation, including, but not limited to, any tax, zoning,
planning, or sanitation regulations, and any inspection service in its
police jurisdiction located in Lawrence County and to provide that a
municipality prohibited from imposing any tax or regulation under this
amendment shall not provide any regulatory function or police or fire
protection services in its police jurisdiction located in Lawrence
County, other than public safety mutual aid. (Proposed by Act No.
2012-308)
This is intended to prevent the city of Decatur from overpowering Lawrence County without a vote of the people. Vote YES.
There is also a Tuscaloosa County amendment. It is designed to prevent an occupational tax from being implemented by the county government without a vote by the people - see the Tuscaloosa News article here. I don't have the exact wording, but this is a YES vote for Tuscaloosa County residents.
If you have information that contradicts my reading of these amendments, and can deliver it in a way that will enlighten and inform without being belligerent, leave me a comment and I will update this post for the benefit of those who asked for it. Thanks.
Monday, November 05, 2012
Sunday, November 04, 2012
SEC Football Week Ten: The Rundown
Week Ten in the Southeastern Conference saw the third Alabama-LSU matchup within the last 12 months, and this one was the best game of the three. A team that was undefeated a week ago is now reeling from two straight blowouts. Three beleaguered teams got much-needed wins, while a fourth received a crushing defeat. And the division leaders can finally see light at the end of the tunnel. Let's start the rundown!
1. Alabama faces its toughest test of the year and comes out on top.
While (1) Alabama went into Saturday's game with (5) LSU in Baton Rouge with a clear advantage on paper, the intangibles all favored LSU. First, you had the night game atmosphere of Tiger Stadium, where the Tigers were 36-1 under Les Miles going into the game. You had a team that was embarrassed in the national championship game going into a home game as a 10-point underdog, something that had never happened in Miles' tenure. You had virtually everyone saying that the Tigers' offense was inferior to Alabama's, and you had an Alabama team that had not needed to play four full quarters of football all year. LSU played their best game of the year, outgaining the Tide 435 yards to 331, and Tigers quarterback Zach Mettenberger was consistently accurate. With 1:31 remaining in the game and no timeouts, Alabama trailed LSU 17-14 and needed to go 72 yards to score. AJ McCarron led a masterful 43-second drive culminating in a 28-yard touchdown pass on a screen play to T. J. Yeldon to preserve the national and SEC championship hopes for the Crimson Tide.
2. Texas A&M hammers another SEC West opponent.
Fresh off a 63-21 shellacking of Auburn on the road last week, (16) Texas A&M traveled to Starkville to face a Mississippi State team whose confidence was shaken after experiencing their first loss of the season in Tuscaloosa last week. Unfortunately for the 15th-ranked Bulldogs, the Aggies picked up right where they left off, jumping out to a 24-0 first half lead, the same margin, incidentally, that Alabama had amassed in the first half the week before. The Bulldogs were unable to get up off the mat, falling 38-13. It is evident that MSU is now paying the dues on its lightweight early schedule, as 7-0 is now 7-2, with a trip to Baton Rouge on the horizon. Johnny Manziel, the SEC's leading rusher and the Aggies' superstar freshman quarterback threw 30 completions on 36 passes for 311 yards and ran for two touchdowns, and A&M is still mathematically in contention for the SEC West in November. That's a remarkable achievement for a first-year team (ask Missouri) and Aggies are loving their new QB, new coach, and new conference.
3. Everyone who needs a win, step forward. Not so fast, Kentucky.
There are four head coaches in the SEC whose jobs are in serious jeopardy, and while each of them arguably are past the point of no return, each team had an opportunity Saturday to turn their fortunes around, however fleetingly. Auburn doubled its win total for the season with a 42-7 victory over New Mexico State, and had its best offensive performance of the year with a new quarterback under center. Forget that the NMSU Aggies are 1-8 and in last place in the WAC, which won't even exist after this season. Arkansas struggled to put Tulsa away, scoring a late touchdown to eke out a 19-15 win. The Golden Hurricane is a good Conference-USA team, but the Razorbacks face three straight ranked SEC opponents to close the season, so the fans should savor this one. Tennessee scored 55 points at home against Troy. Unfortunately, the Vols gave up 48, and had to score a touchdown with 1:25 left in the fourth to seal the win. While none of these wins will do much to preserve the jobs of Gene Chizik, John L. Smith or Derek Dooley, at least they didn't lose any more ground - like, say, Joker Phillips. Kentucky faced Vanderbilt, which may well have been the toughest opponent of the four, and laid an egg, succumbing to the Commodores by a margin of 40-0.
4. SEC Championship Game matchup is all but certain.
While neither team will be able to clinch their respective divisions until next week, both Alabama and Georgia jumped arguably their most difficult remaining hurdles on Saturday. The Bulldogs' 37-10 win at home over Ole Miss keeps them a game ahead of Florida with only 2-7 Auburn remaining on their schedule in SEC play. Alabama has both Texas A&M and Auburn left to play in the conference, but the victory over LSU means that 'Bama would have to lose both games to miss out on a trip to Atlanta. The teams were originally supposed to play each other in the regular season this year, but the addition of two teams to the SEC forced major changes to the 2012 schedule. Much was made in the off-season about Georgia avoiding what were perceived to be the major powers in the West for the second year in a row, since the Bulldogs didn't have to play Alabama, LSU or Arkansas. However, the East turned out to be much stronger than anticipated, and while Georgia ran an easier gauntlet than either Florida or South Carolina, the Bulldogs did what they had to do to return to the title game for the second straight year. There has been less talk about Alabama's path to Atlanta, although the Crimson Tide has also been aided by a schedule missing the top three teams in the SEC East. Alabama and Georgia have never played each other in the SEC Championship Game, and the last meeting between the two teams was in the 2008 "Blackout Game," won 41-30 by the Tide. Alabama leads the all-time series 36-25-4.
5. The Good
(1) Alabama 21, (5) LSU 17
LSU dominated this game statistically. The Tigers had more first downs than Alabama (22-18), didn't turn the ball over ('Bama fumbled twice), and converted 50% of their third downs (10 of 20) while the Tide struggled (1 of 9 for 11%). Mettenberger threw for nearly 300 yards. Jeremy Hill ran for 107 and a touchdown. The Tide hadn't allowed a 100-yard rusher in two years. While Les Miles made a few head-scratching decisions that looked poor in hindsight, he and his team threw everything they had at Alabama, clearly benefiting from an extra week of preparation and a determination to take more risks than in the last meeting in New Orleans. Despite all of that, 'Bama did something that it hadn't had to do all season - something that all championship teams have to do - find a way to win. The defending national champs were outplayed in the entire second half, but with the game on the line the Crimson Tide broke the hearts of the Bayou Bengals and salvaged the season.
(16) Texas A&M 38, (15) Mississippi State 13
The Aggies have won all five of their road games this season, and they ran the Bulldogs off the field in impressive fashion. If anything, this game wasn't as close as the score indicates, as A&M outgained the Bulldogs by nearly 400 yards and amassed 21 more first downs. Yikes. Something tells me we have seen the last of those all-white "Snow Bowl" uniforms from Mississippi State. Texas A&M, on the other hand, might want to keep those new black duds handy.
(6) Georgia 37, Ole Miss 10
Georgia spotted the Rebels the first ten points, obviously suffering a bit of a hangover after last week's big win over Florida, but the Bulldogs scored two second quarter touchdowns on great plays by quarterback Aaron Murray and went on to blank Ole Miss the rest of the way. Georgia outgained the Rebels by 299 yards of offense and Murray threw four touchdowns with no interceptions on the day.
Vanderbilt 40, Kentucky 0
The Commodores exploded for 20 second-quarter points, scoring touchdowns on four of its five first half drives in the worst defeat of Kentucky by Vandy since 1916. The Commodores are one win away from bowl eligibility with games remaining against Ole Miss, Tennessee and Wake Forest. It is only sporting to pull for the 'Dores to make it to what would be only their six bowl appearance of all time (the next-closest conference teams, MSU and Kentucky, both currently have 15).
Auburn 42, New Mexico State 7
It would be a mistake to think that a win Saturday changes anything significant on the Plains, but at this point Auburn fans will take any success they can get. The Tigers had two rushers over 100 yards, and Jonathan Wallace was solid in his first start, passing for 164 yards and a touchdown.
6. The Bad
Tennessee 55, Troy 48
Tennessee's Pyrrhic victory over Troy saw the Trojans amass 721 yards of offense, take the lead three times, and force the Vols to score two touchdowns in the last three minutes to secure the win. Keep in mind Troy lost to lowly Florida Atlantic last week. I'm starting to wonder if Nick Saban actually sent Sal Sunseri to Tennessee as a double agent to destroy the Volunteers' defense. Well played, Coach.
7. The Ugly
(7) Florida 14, Missouri 7
The Gators took last week's loss to Georgia hard. The out-manned Missouri squad put up a valiant effort in the Swamp, but the disinterested Gators finally managed to salt away the win. Florida needed four interceptions, including one in the end zone with five seconds remaining on the clock, to put away the Tigers and keep themselves alive for a BCS bowl and an outside shot at the SEC title game.
Arkansas 19, Tulsa 15
Although Tulsa had only lost one game coming in to Fayetteville, the Golden Hurricane has played a pretty atrocious set of teams. The Razorbacks jumped out to an early 10-0 lead, but sleepwalked through the next two quarters. Midway through the third, Tulsa kicked a field goal to go up 15-13. Arkansas scored soon after to retake a four-point lead, but missed the two-point conversion. Then the Razorbacks missed a field goal and bypassed another attempt for a field goal to go for it on fourth down, which they also failed to convert. Fortunately, Tulsa was unable to capitalize on their fourth quarter opportunities, and Arkansas escaped with an ugly win.
8. Games to Watch in Week Eleven
Texas A&M (7-2) at Alabama (9-0)
The Aggies face the Crimson Tide for just the fifth time and the first ever in Tuscaloosa. These two programs have a lot of history together, sharing three coaches - Paul W. "Bear" Bryant, Gene Stallings, and Dennis Franchione - although both teams probably want to forget that last one. Still, this A&M squad is focused on the present, not the past, and nothing would cap their inaugural season in the SEC like a win over the top-ranked Crimson Tide. Alabama will be coming off an emotional road win and facing a completely different type of team than LSU. 'Bama's vaunted defense was exposed in Baton Rouge, and they will need to regroup quickly to keep the Tide's title hopes alive. I am leaning toward an Alabama win, but I expect this to be a nailbiter.
Mississippi State (7-2) at LSU (7-2)
The Bulldogs have been manhandled the last two weeks, and LSU has proven to be on par with the two teams that did the manhandling. I would not expect Mississippi State to have much of a chance, but last night's devastating loss could carry over into next week if the Tigers let it. I expect a sloppy game and an LSU win.
Georgia (8-1) at Auburn (2-7)
The South's Oldest Rivalry has seen better games. Georgia needs this win to go to Atlanta, while Auburn is only playing for pride and a chance to ruin the Bulldogs' title run. The Tigers won't win, but I think that they will keep it closer than expected.
South Carolina (7-2) at Arkansas (4-5)
The Gamecocks have had a week to recover from the devastating injury to Marcus Lattimore, and I expect it to bring the team together. Arkansas's chance at a bowl is on the line, but I predicted South Carolina to win this game in the preseason when the Razorbacks were still expected to be a top 10 team, and nothing I've seen this season makes me think that they can pull off the upset.
Vanderbilt (5-4) at Ole Miss (5-4)
While this is certainly not a marquee game, both teams are looking for bowl eligibility, and this has become a fairly big rivalry for both schools since the 1970s. Vandy has won five of the last seven, but I give the edge to the Rebels.
Missouri (4-5) at Tennessee (4-5)
Mizzou's first season in the SEC has not turned out like they had hoped. Tennessee's three-year run under Dooley has been its worst in decades. Both teams need this win to keep their slim bowl hopes alive, but frankly, the fact that either of them could go to a bowl is an indictment of the current bowl system. Tennessee doesn't have much defense, but the injury-riddled Tigers won't be able to make them pay for that. I'm picking the Volunteers to win.
This is shaping up to be one of the most interesting slate of SEC games this season. Enjoy.
1. Alabama faces its toughest test of the year and comes out on top.
While (1) Alabama went into Saturday's game with (5) LSU in Baton Rouge with a clear advantage on paper, the intangibles all favored LSU. First, you had the night game atmosphere of Tiger Stadium, where the Tigers were 36-1 under Les Miles going into the game. You had a team that was embarrassed in the national championship game going into a home game as a 10-point underdog, something that had never happened in Miles' tenure. You had virtually everyone saying that the Tigers' offense was inferior to Alabama's, and you had an Alabama team that had not needed to play four full quarters of football all year. LSU played their best game of the year, outgaining the Tide 435 yards to 331, and Tigers quarterback Zach Mettenberger was consistently accurate. With 1:31 remaining in the game and no timeouts, Alabama trailed LSU 17-14 and needed to go 72 yards to score. AJ McCarron led a masterful 43-second drive culminating in a 28-yard touchdown pass on a screen play to T. J. Yeldon to preserve the national and SEC championship hopes for the Crimson Tide.
2. Texas A&M hammers another SEC West opponent.
Fresh off a 63-21 shellacking of Auburn on the road last week, (16) Texas A&M traveled to Starkville to face a Mississippi State team whose confidence was shaken after experiencing their first loss of the season in Tuscaloosa last week. Unfortunately for the 15th-ranked Bulldogs, the Aggies picked up right where they left off, jumping out to a 24-0 first half lead, the same margin, incidentally, that Alabama had amassed in the first half the week before. The Bulldogs were unable to get up off the mat, falling 38-13. It is evident that MSU is now paying the dues on its lightweight early schedule, as 7-0 is now 7-2, with a trip to Baton Rouge on the horizon. Johnny Manziel, the SEC's leading rusher and the Aggies' superstar freshman quarterback threw 30 completions on 36 passes for 311 yards and ran for two touchdowns, and A&M is still mathematically in contention for the SEC West in November. That's a remarkable achievement for a first-year team (ask Missouri) and Aggies are loving their new QB, new coach, and new conference.
3. Everyone who needs a win, step forward. Not so fast, Kentucky.
There are four head coaches in the SEC whose jobs are in serious jeopardy, and while each of them arguably are past the point of no return, each team had an opportunity Saturday to turn their fortunes around, however fleetingly. Auburn doubled its win total for the season with a 42-7 victory over New Mexico State, and had its best offensive performance of the year with a new quarterback under center. Forget that the NMSU Aggies are 1-8 and in last place in the WAC, which won't even exist after this season. Arkansas struggled to put Tulsa away, scoring a late touchdown to eke out a 19-15 win. The Golden Hurricane is a good Conference-USA team, but the Razorbacks face three straight ranked SEC opponents to close the season, so the fans should savor this one. Tennessee scored 55 points at home against Troy. Unfortunately, the Vols gave up 48, and had to score a touchdown with 1:25 left in the fourth to seal the win. While none of these wins will do much to preserve the jobs of Gene Chizik, John L. Smith or Derek Dooley, at least they didn't lose any more ground - like, say, Joker Phillips. Kentucky faced Vanderbilt, which may well have been the toughest opponent of the four, and laid an egg, succumbing to the Commodores by a margin of 40-0.
4. SEC Championship Game matchup is all but certain.
While neither team will be able to clinch their respective divisions until next week, both Alabama and Georgia jumped arguably their most difficult remaining hurdles on Saturday. The Bulldogs' 37-10 win at home over Ole Miss keeps them a game ahead of Florida with only 2-7 Auburn remaining on their schedule in SEC play. Alabama has both Texas A&M and Auburn left to play in the conference, but the victory over LSU means that 'Bama would have to lose both games to miss out on a trip to Atlanta. The teams were originally supposed to play each other in the regular season this year, but the addition of two teams to the SEC forced major changes to the 2012 schedule. Much was made in the off-season about Georgia avoiding what were perceived to be the major powers in the West for the second year in a row, since the Bulldogs didn't have to play Alabama, LSU or Arkansas. However, the East turned out to be much stronger than anticipated, and while Georgia ran an easier gauntlet than either Florida or South Carolina, the Bulldogs did what they had to do to return to the title game for the second straight year. There has been less talk about Alabama's path to Atlanta, although the Crimson Tide has also been aided by a schedule missing the top three teams in the SEC East. Alabama and Georgia have never played each other in the SEC Championship Game, and the last meeting between the two teams was in the 2008 "Blackout Game," won 41-30 by the Tide. Alabama leads the all-time series 36-25-4.
5. The Good
(1) Alabama 21, (5) LSU 17
LSU dominated this game statistically. The Tigers had more first downs than Alabama (22-18), didn't turn the ball over ('Bama fumbled twice), and converted 50% of their third downs (10 of 20) while the Tide struggled (1 of 9 for 11%). Mettenberger threw for nearly 300 yards. Jeremy Hill ran for 107 and a touchdown. The Tide hadn't allowed a 100-yard rusher in two years. While Les Miles made a few head-scratching decisions that looked poor in hindsight, he and his team threw everything they had at Alabama, clearly benefiting from an extra week of preparation and a determination to take more risks than in the last meeting in New Orleans. Despite all of that, 'Bama did something that it hadn't had to do all season - something that all championship teams have to do - find a way to win. The defending national champs were outplayed in the entire second half, but with the game on the line the Crimson Tide broke the hearts of the Bayou Bengals and salvaged the season.
(16) Texas A&M 38, (15) Mississippi State 13
The Aggies have won all five of their road games this season, and they ran the Bulldogs off the field in impressive fashion. If anything, this game wasn't as close as the score indicates, as A&M outgained the Bulldogs by nearly 400 yards and amassed 21 more first downs. Yikes. Something tells me we have seen the last of those all-white "Snow Bowl" uniforms from Mississippi State. Texas A&M, on the other hand, might want to keep those new black duds handy.
(6) Georgia 37, Ole Miss 10
Georgia spotted the Rebels the first ten points, obviously suffering a bit of a hangover after last week's big win over Florida, but the Bulldogs scored two second quarter touchdowns on great plays by quarterback Aaron Murray and went on to blank Ole Miss the rest of the way. Georgia outgained the Rebels by 299 yards of offense and Murray threw four touchdowns with no interceptions on the day.
Vanderbilt 40, Kentucky 0
The Commodores exploded for 20 second-quarter points, scoring touchdowns on four of its five first half drives in the worst defeat of Kentucky by Vandy since 1916. The Commodores are one win away from bowl eligibility with games remaining against Ole Miss, Tennessee and Wake Forest. It is only sporting to pull for the 'Dores to make it to what would be only their six bowl appearance of all time (the next-closest conference teams, MSU and Kentucky, both currently have 15).
Auburn 42, New Mexico State 7
It would be a mistake to think that a win Saturday changes anything significant on the Plains, but at this point Auburn fans will take any success they can get. The Tigers had two rushers over 100 yards, and Jonathan Wallace was solid in his first start, passing for 164 yards and a touchdown.
6. The Bad
Tennessee 55, Troy 48
Tennessee's Pyrrhic victory over Troy saw the Trojans amass 721 yards of offense, take the lead three times, and force the Vols to score two touchdowns in the last three minutes to secure the win. Keep in mind Troy lost to lowly Florida Atlantic last week. I'm starting to wonder if Nick Saban actually sent Sal Sunseri to Tennessee as a double agent to destroy the Volunteers' defense. Well played, Coach.
7. The Ugly
(7) Florida 14, Missouri 7
The Gators took last week's loss to Georgia hard. The out-manned Missouri squad put up a valiant effort in the Swamp, but the disinterested Gators finally managed to salt away the win. Florida needed four interceptions, including one in the end zone with five seconds remaining on the clock, to put away the Tigers and keep themselves alive for a BCS bowl and an outside shot at the SEC title game.
Arkansas 19, Tulsa 15
Although Tulsa had only lost one game coming in to Fayetteville, the Golden Hurricane has played a pretty atrocious set of teams. The Razorbacks jumped out to an early 10-0 lead, but sleepwalked through the next two quarters. Midway through the third, Tulsa kicked a field goal to go up 15-13. Arkansas scored soon after to retake a four-point lead, but missed the two-point conversion. Then the Razorbacks missed a field goal and bypassed another attempt for a field goal to go for it on fourth down, which they also failed to convert. Fortunately, Tulsa was unable to capitalize on their fourth quarter opportunities, and Arkansas escaped with an ugly win.
8. Games to Watch in Week Eleven
Texas A&M (7-2) at Alabama (9-0)
The Aggies face the Crimson Tide for just the fifth time and the first ever in Tuscaloosa. These two programs have a lot of history together, sharing three coaches - Paul W. "Bear" Bryant, Gene Stallings, and Dennis Franchione - although both teams probably want to forget that last one. Still, this A&M squad is focused on the present, not the past, and nothing would cap their inaugural season in the SEC like a win over the top-ranked Crimson Tide. Alabama will be coming off an emotional road win and facing a completely different type of team than LSU. 'Bama's vaunted defense was exposed in Baton Rouge, and they will need to regroup quickly to keep the Tide's title hopes alive. I am leaning toward an Alabama win, but I expect this to be a nailbiter.
Mississippi State (7-2) at LSU (7-2)
The Bulldogs have been manhandled the last two weeks, and LSU has proven to be on par with the two teams that did the manhandling. I would not expect Mississippi State to have much of a chance, but last night's devastating loss could carry over into next week if the Tigers let it. I expect a sloppy game and an LSU win.
Georgia (8-1) at Auburn (2-7)
The South's Oldest Rivalry has seen better games. Georgia needs this win to go to Atlanta, while Auburn is only playing for pride and a chance to ruin the Bulldogs' title run. The Tigers won't win, but I think that they will keep it closer than expected.
South Carolina (7-2) at Arkansas (4-5)
The Gamecocks have had a week to recover from the devastating injury to Marcus Lattimore, and I expect it to bring the team together. Arkansas's chance at a bowl is on the line, but I predicted South Carolina to win this game in the preseason when the Razorbacks were still expected to be a top 10 team, and nothing I've seen this season makes me think that they can pull off the upset.
Vanderbilt (5-4) at Ole Miss (5-4)
While this is certainly not a marquee game, both teams are looking for bowl eligibility, and this has become a fairly big rivalry for both schools since the 1970s. Vandy has won five of the last seven, but I give the edge to the Rebels.
Missouri (4-5) at Tennessee (4-5)
Mizzou's first season in the SEC has not turned out like they had hoped. Tennessee's three-year run under Dooley has been its worst in decades. Both teams need this win to keep their slim bowl hopes alive, but frankly, the fact that either of them could go to a bowl is an indictment of the current bowl system. Tennessee doesn't have much defense, but the injury-riddled Tigers won't be able to make them pay for that. I'm picking the Volunteers to win.
This is shaping up to be one of the most interesting slate of SEC games this season. Enjoy.
Sunday, October 28, 2012
SEC Football Week Nine: The Rundown
This week we saw the SEC East basically wrapped up by the team everyone expected to win it in the first place, an undefeated team that wasn't ready for prime time and another that won its first SEC game. We also saw every coach on the "hot seat" lose, a new coach achieving a milestone, and the number of unblemished teams in the SEC narrowed to one. Let's start the Rundown!
1. Congratulations to Georgia, I guess.
I give credit to Georgia for one thing - when they put some emotional effort into a game, they are a pretty good team. Fortunately for the Bulldogs, they have been able to phone it in for a good part of the season and still get into position to take the lead in the SEC East away from Florida. Unfortunately for the Bulldogs, they looked as undisciplined as ever, amassing 14 penalties and three turnovers in a sloppily played 17-9 victory. But the Gators looked even worse, losing four fumbles, throwing two interceptions and garnering ten penalties of their own. Didn't anyone on the Florida team read my blog post last week where I said turnovers are bad? Georgia still has to beat a decent Ole Miss team at home, then will close their SEC schedule against the worst Auburn team in decades, but Florida was the largest hurdle left for the 'Dawgs on the way to Atlanta.
2. #FailState.
Mississippi State and its fans have embraced Twitter, using the #HailState and #WeBelieve hashtags to send pictures from around the world to encourage each other and their team on to victory. That's okay as far as it goes, and fans with posters stating "8-0. We Believe" and cowbells getting pictures made at the White House, Times Square, the Eiffel Tower and whatnot are all well and good. But if you are going to do something like this:
You might want to wait until the game is over, or at least until you have a team that can actually pull it off.
3. Hugh Freeze may be SEC Coach of the Year.
One week after winning their first conference game in two years, Freeze's Rebels have doubled that total and are one win away from bowl eligibility. Saturday's 30-27 win over Arkansas, like last week's victory over Auburn, was admittedly far from perfect, and neither opponent is likely to make a bowl game, but Ole Miss already looks like a much better team than they did under the last two years of Houston Nutt's tenure. It remains to be seen whether Freeze can recruit well enough to move to the next level, but opponents are already having to change their view of the Rebels from an easy out to a dangerous opponent. That's a big accomplishment, and if Freeze can find one or two more wins and makes a bowl - no easy task - I think he locks up the vote for SEC Coach of the Year.
4. The Good.
(1) Alabama 38, (11) Mississippi State 7
Alabama has made every opponent look vastly inferior this year by following the same formula - offensive balance; stifling defense, especially in the red zone; and forcing and capitalizing on mistakes by their opponents. AJ McCarron hasn't thrown an interception all year and is only two touchdowns away from tying Greg McElroy's single-season school record. The Tide's defense held State 100 yards below their season average, forced three turnovers from the nation's leader in turnover margin, and held the SEC's leading rusher, LaDarius Perkins, to just 38 yards on 15 carries.
Ole Miss 30, Arkansas 27
Mississippi quarterback Bo Wallace led the Rebels on an eight play, 61-yard drive to score the game-winning field goal as time expired. Wallace was responsible for 316 yards of total offense for Ole Miss, completing 29 of 37 passes for 278 yards and rushing for another 38 yards on eleven carries.
Missouri 33, Kentucky 10
While it took three-quarters of the season to do so, Missouri won its first SEC game Saturday behind a strong finish by quarterback James Franklin, who replaced Corbin Berkstresser in the third quarter after he threw two consecutive interceptions. The Tigers evened their record at 4-4.
Vanderbilt 49, Massachusetts 7
The Commodores scored two touchdowns in the last 55 seconds of the second half, then blew the game open with four touchdowns in the third quarter to put away a winless UMass team that is inaugurating its first season in FBS in grand style.
5. The Bad.
(13) South Carolina 38, Tennessee 35
South Carolina's Marcus Lattimore, who returned this season from a devastating knee injury in 2011, appeared to severely damage his other knee on a routine tackle in the second quarter of the game. The love of his teammates and respect of his opponents was abundantly clear as Lattimore was carted off the field. Season-ending injuries are hard enough. Having two of them in successive seasons, putting his future on the football field in doubt, is a tough pill to swallow, and it's something that no football fan wants to see.
(20) Texas A&M 63, Auburn 21
I'm running out of adjectives to describe how terrible this Auburn team is. The Aggies outgained Auburn 671 yards (an all-time record for an Auburn opponent) to 335. The game was over by the end of the first quarter, and at this point winning next week over 1-7 New Mexico State is going to look like an achievement.
6. The Ugly.
(10) Georgia 17, (2) Florida 9
This game featured nine turnovers, 24 penalties, and several dustups that looked to be a second or two away from a full-blown fistfight. The result was an ugly performance from both teams, although Georgia fans are glad to get away from Jacksonville with only their fifth victory over Florida in their last 23 matchups.
7. Games to Watch in Week Ten.
(1) Alabama at (5) LSU
The Crimson Tide will face their sternest test of the 2012 season so far as they travel to Baton Rouge to face LSU. The Tigers are still the best team that 'Bama will face in the regular season and, although the Tide used to pay rent on Tiger Stadium (because they owned it, you see), night games there are notoriously hard to win in the Les Miles era. I give Alabama the edge due to LSU's offensive woes, but I expect another close game.
(16) Texas A&M at (15) Mississippi State
This is a tough game to predict. I know Texas A&M is a good team and, coming off an easy win over Auburn, is pretty well rested for this game. I also know that the Aggies might be tempted to look ahead to top-ranked Alabama week after next. I know the Bulldogs were beat up a little bit against Alabama, and haven't faced as brutal a schedule as the Aggies. I also know that State is playing at home and they have a lot left to play for in 2012. I think this is pretty much a tossup, but I lean toward the home-standing Bulldogs in this one.
Ole Miss at (6) Georgia
Georgia should be able to handle Ole Miss, but it will be interesting to see if the Bulldogs have any kind of letdown after the Florida win. In addition, I want to see what Ole Miss looks like against better competition than their last two SEC opponents. I expect a Georgia win, but a close game, at least for the first half.
1. Congratulations to Georgia, I guess.
I give credit to Georgia for one thing - when they put some emotional effort into a game, they are a pretty good team. Fortunately for the Bulldogs, they have been able to phone it in for a good part of the season and still get into position to take the lead in the SEC East away from Florida. Unfortunately for the Bulldogs, they looked as undisciplined as ever, amassing 14 penalties and three turnovers in a sloppily played 17-9 victory. But the Gators looked even worse, losing four fumbles, throwing two interceptions and garnering ten penalties of their own. Didn't anyone on the Florida team read my blog post last week where I said turnovers are bad? Georgia still has to beat a decent Ole Miss team at home, then will close their SEC schedule against the worst Auburn team in decades, but Florida was the largest hurdle left for the 'Dawgs on the way to Atlanta.
2. #FailState.
Mississippi State and its fans have embraced Twitter, using the #HailState and #WeBelieve hashtags to send pictures from around the world to encourage each other and their team on to victory. That's okay as far as it goes, and fans with posters stating "8-0. We Believe" and cowbells getting pictures made at the White House, Times Square, the Eiffel Tower and whatnot are all well and good. But if you are going to do something like this:
You might want to wait until the game is over, or at least until you have a team that can actually pull it off.
3. Hugh Freeze may be SEC Coach of the Year.
One week after winning their first conference game in two years, Freeze's Rebels have doubled that total and are one win away from bowl eligibility. Saturday's 30-27 win over Arkansas, like last week's victory over Auburn, was admittedly far from perfect, and neither opponent is likely to make a bowl game, but Ole Miss already looks like a much better team than they did under the last two years of Houston Nutt's tenure. It remains to be seen whether Freeze can recruit well enough to move to the next level, but opponents are already having to change their view of the Rebels from an easy out to a dangerous opponent. That's a big accomplishment, and if Freeze can find one or two more wins and makes a bowl - no easy task - I think he locks up the vote for SEC Coach of the Year.
4. The Good.
(1) Alabama 38, (11) Mississippi State 7
Alabama has made every opponent look vastly inferior this year by following the same formula - offensive balance; stifling defense, especially in the red zone; and forcing and capitalizing on mistakes by their opponents. AJ McCarron hasn't thrown an interception all year and is only two touchdowns away from tying Greg McElroy's single-season school record. The Tide's defense held State 100 yards below their season average, forced three turnovers from the nation's leader in turnover margin, and held the SEC's leading rusher, LaDarius Perkins, to just 38 yards on 15 carries.
Ole Miss 30, Arkansas 27
Mississippi quarterback Bo Wallace led the Rebels on an eight play, 61-yard drive to score the game-winning field goal as time expired. Wallace was responsible for 316 yards of total offense for Ole Miss, completing 29 of 37 passes for 278 yards and rushing for another 38 yards on eleven carries.
Missouri 33, Kentucky 10
While it took three-quarters of the season to do so, Missouri won its first SEC game Saturday behind a strong finish by quarterback James Franklin, who replaced Corbin Berkstresser in the third quarter after he threw two consecutive interceptions. The Tigers evened their record at 4-4.
Vanderbilt 49, Massachusetts 7
The Commodores scored two touchdowns in the last 55 seconds of the second half, then blew the game open with four touchdowns in the third quarter to put away a winless UMass team that is inaugurating its first season in FBS in grand style.
5. The Bad.
(13) South Carolina 38, Tennessee 35
South Carolina's Marcus Lattimore, who returned this season from a devastating knee injury in 2011, appeared to severely damage his other knee on a routine tackle in the second quarter of the game. The love of his teammates and respect of his opponents was abundantly clear as Lattimore was carted off the field. Season-ending injuries are hard enough. Having two of them in successive seasons, putting his future on the football field in doubt, is a tough pill to swallow, and it's something that no football fan wants to see.
(20) Texas A&M 63, Auburn 21
I'm running out of adjectives to describe how terrible this Auburn team is. The Aggies outgained Auburn 671 yards (an all-time record for an Auburn opponent) to 335. The game was over by the end of the first quarter, and at this point winning next week over 1-7 New Mexico State is going to look like an achievement.
6. The Ugly.
(10) Georgia 17, (2) Florida 9
This game featured nine turnovers, 24 penalties, and several dustups that looked to be a second or two away from a full-blown fistfight. The result was an ugly performance from both teams, although Georgia fans are glad to get away from Jacksonville with only their fifth victory over Florida in their last 23 matchups.
7. Games to Watch in Week Ten.
(1) Alabama at (5) LSU
The Crimson Tide will face their sternest test of the 2012 season so far as they travel to Baton Rouge to face LSU. The Tigers are still the best team that 'Bama will face in the regular season and, although the Tide used to pay rent on Tiger Stadium (because they owned it, you see), night games there are notoriously hard to win in the Les Miles era. I give Alabama the edge due to LSU's offensive woes, but I expect another close game.
(16) Texas A&M at (15) Mississippi State
This is a tough game to predict. I know Texas A&M is a good team and, coming off an easy win over Auburn, is pretty well rested for this game. I also know that the Aggies might be tempted to look ahead to top-ranked Alabama week after next. I know the Bulldogs were beat up a little bit against Alabama, and haven't faced as brutal a schedule as the Aggies. I also know that State is playing at home and they have a lot left to play for in 2012. I think this is pretty much a tossup, but I lean toward the home-standing Bulldogs in this one.
Ole Miss at (6) Georgia
Georgia should be able to handle Ole Miss, but it will be interesting to see if the Bulldogs have any kind of letdown after the Florida win. In addition, I want to see what Ole Miss looks like against better competition than their last two SEC opponents. I expect a Georgia win, but a close game, at least for the first half.
Friday, October 26, 2012
Alabama and the 14 National Championships, Part II
Part I
In the first part of this series, I reviewed Alabama's fourteen claimed national championships, including the season results and how Alabama arrived at that number. In my opinion, thirteen of those titles are very hard to dispute, although the 1941 championship is pretty dubious. The College Football Data Warehouse (CFDW) web site, agrees that Alabama has 13 "recognized" national championships, but lists 27 total. So, if Alabama claims fourteen of those titles, what about the other thirteen? Are any of those titles "legitimate?"
Everyone knows that the BCS era has eliminated multiple national champions, right? After cruising through the regular season undefeated in 2011, top-ranked LSU made it to the BCS National Championship Game and met second-ranked Alabama for the title. Alabama beat LSU 21-0, and everybody agreed that they won the Mythical National Championship (MNC), or did they?
As a matter of fact, many people felt like Oklahoma State, who finished third in the BCS, deserved to play in the title game, since LSU had already defeated 'Bama in the regular season (a 9-6 win in overtime). Others were less concerned about the fact that the Tigers and the Tide had already played each other, and more about the fact that Alabama had not won its conference title, as LSU and Okie State had. While Alabama won the championship game, three selectors (1st-N-Goal, CBSSportsLine, and Colley) chose Oklahoma State as the 2011 national champ. In fact, Congrove and the Seattle Times, chose LSU as the 2011 national champion, basically stating that the bowl game was meaningless! How's that for irony, given the so-called dispute over Alabama's 1964 and 1973 titles? So, is Oklahoma State's claim to the 2011 title illegitimate?
In 2004, the Auburn Tigers finished 13-0-0, winning the SEC Championship and the Sugar Bowl over Virginia Tech. Unfortunately, Auburn had been ranked seventeenth in the AP poll and eighteenth in the Coaches poll, while USC and Oklahoma started the season ranked number 1 and number 2, and never lost. Auburn was shut out of the title game, which USC won and subsequently vacated. At the time, Auburn was named as a national champion by two small-time selectors. Is that claim illegitimate?
In 2003, the regular college football season ended with three teams in title contention - USC (ranked #1 in the AP and Coaches Poll), LSU (ranked #2 in both) and Oklahoma (ranked #3). Each team had one loss. The BCS formula selected LSU and Oklahoma to play in the Sugar Bowl for the national title, while USC played fourth-ranked Michigan in the Rose Bowl. The AP chose USC as national champ, while the Coaches Poll, which is obligated to select the BCS champion, selected LSU. Are either of their claims illegitimate?
My point is that even in an era where the "top two" teams are matched up in a BCS title game, the definition of which teams are the top two, and even who won the title, are still controversial. Good cases can be made for several teams every year, and that was even more true in the days before the BCS, when there was no guarantee that the top-ranked teams would (or even could) play each other. Without a large-scale playoff system, a large part of every MNC is based on a beauty contest - which games were won by how many points, who did you lose to, what conference are you from, etc. So, it's fair to say that even in the years that there is a consensus about the champion, there is often a case to be made for someone else. With that being said, let's take a look at the thirteen "lost championships" and see whether any of them make a fair case for the Tide.
Anyway, there you have it. Alabama has fourteen claimed national titles, thirteen of which stand on very solid footing. Additionally, the Crimson Tide could lay claim to up to thirteen other titles, and while a few of these are iffy, a fair case could easily be made for a few of them, particularly 1936, 1945, 1966, and 1977. I feel pretty certain that Alabama isn't going to back off of the 1941 title claim at this point, as it has memorialized that season in statue and stone, as well as numerous T-shirts, flags, bumper stickers, and whatnot. However, at least when some ignorant Barner makes a comment about "NASHUNAL CHAMPEANS, PAWWWWLLL," you can rest easy knowing that whatever the number may legitimately be, it is way more than Auburn has. Furthermore, the Tide isn't the only team that claims more titles than are broadly recognized. I'll leave you with this list of all teams with at least three recognized titles (to include Auburn).
Team Titles Recognized Titles Claimed Total (All Selectors)
Princeton 26 28 31
Yale 18 27 31
Alabama 13 14 27
Notre Dame 13 11 23
Michigan 11 11 21
USC 10 11 22
Pittsburgh 9 9 16
Harvard 8 8 19
Ohio State 7 7 20
Oklahoma 7 7 23
Minnesota 6 7 10
Pennsylvania 6 7 21
Army 5 3 11
Miami 5 5 10
Nebraska 5 5 14
California 4 5 5
Georgia Tech 4 4 7
Illinois 4 5 6
LSU 4 3 11
Michigan State 4 6 8
Penn State 4 2 15
Tennessee 4 6 14
Texas 4 4 13
Auburn 3 3 8
Cornell 3 5 5
Florida 3 3 5
Lafayette 3 3 3
Props to Cal and Cornell for straight up, unabashedly claiming all of theirs, deservedly or not.
*(Note: In fact, the Big Ten abolished the rule that kept Michigan State from repeating its trip to the Rose Bowl in 1972 and the rule that prevented them from accepting an invitation from another bowl prior to the 1975 season. Notre Dame did not accept a bowl invitation from 1924 to 1969. The Big Ten and Notre Dame had both, in the mid 1920s, made a decision to decline all bowl offers as a protest against the commercialization of college football. The Big Ten's ban lasted 26 years, Notre Dame's 45.)
In the first part of this series, I reviewed Alabama's fourteen claimed national championships, including the season results and how Alabama arrived at that number. In my opinion, thirteen of those titles are very hard to dispute, although the 1941 championship is pretty dubious. The College Football Data Warehouse (CFDW) web site, agrees that Alabama has 13 "recognized" national championships, but lists 27 total. So, if Alabama claims fourteen of those titles, what about the other thirteen? Are any of those titles "legitimate?"
Everyone knows that the BCS era has eliminated multiple national champions, right? After cruising through the regular season undefeated in 2011, top-ranked LSU made it to the BCS National Championship Game and met second-ranked Alabama for the title. Alabama beat LSU 21-0, and everybody agreed that they won the Mythical National Championship (MNC), or did they?
As a matter of fact, many people felt like Oklahoma State, who finished third in the BCS, deserved to play in the title game, since LSU had already defeated 'Bama in the regular season (a 9-6 win in overtime). Others were less concerned about the fact that the Tigers and the Tide had already played each other, and more about the fact that Alabama had not won its conference title, as LSU and Okie State had. While Alabama won the championship game, three selectors (1st-N-Goal, CBSSportsLine, and Colley) chose Oklahoma State as the 2011 national champ. In fact, Congrove and the Seattle Times, chose LSU as the 2011 national champion, basically stating that the bowl game was meaningless! How's that for irony, given the so-called dispute over Alabama's 1964 and 1973 titles? So, is Oklahoma State's claim to the 2011 title illegitimate?
In 2004, the Auburn Tigers finished 13-0-0, winning the SEC Championship and the Sugar Bowl over Virginia Tech. Unfortunately, Auburn had been ranked seventeenth in the AP poll and eighteenth in the Coaches poll, while USC and Oklahoma started the season ranked number 1 and number 2, and never lost. Auburn was shut out of the title game, which USC won and subsequently vacated. At the time, Auburn was named as a national champion by two small-time selectors. Is that claim illegitimate?
In 2003, the regular college football season ended with three teams in title contention - USC (ranked #1 in the AP and Coaches Poll), LSU (ranked #2 in both) and Oklahoma (ranked #3). Each team had one loss. The BCS formula selected LSU and Oklahoma to play in the Sugar Bowl for the national title, while USC played fourth-ranked Michigan in the Rose Bowl. The AP chose USC as national champ, while the Coaches Poll, which is obligated to select the BCS champion, selected LSU. Are either of their claims illegitimate?
My point is that even in an era where the "top two" teams are matched up in a BCS title game, the definition of which teams are the top two, and even who won the title, are still controversial. Good cases can be made for several teams every year, and that was even more true in the days before the BCS, when there was no guarantee that the top-ranked teams would (or even could) play each other. Without a large-scale playoff system, a large part of every MNC is based on a beauty contest - which games were won by how many points, who did you lose to, what conference are you from, etc. So, it's fair to say that even in the years that there is a consensus about the champion, there is often a case to be made for someone else. With that being said, let's take a look at the thirteen "lost championships" and see whether any of them make a fair case for the Tide.
- 1936 - Finished 8-0-1 (chosen by four minor selectors, finished 4th in the AP). The only blemish on the Tide's record was a 0-0 tie with Tennessee. The AP (and numerous other selectors) chose Minnesota (7-1-0), who had lost in October to Northwestern, as their national champ, while Pittsburgh (8-1-1 with a loss to Duquesne and a tie versus Fordham's "Seven Blocks of Granite") defeated Washington in the Rose Bowl and was named national champion in ten retroactive polls. Neither Alabama or Minnesota played in a bowl, as the Rose Bowl was the only bowl game played in this era. I think a decent case could be made for Alabama here, given the final record of each of the teams.
- 1937 - Finished 9-1-0 (chosen by Bryne, finished 4th in the AP). Alabama finished the regular season undefeated, but lost the Rose Bowl to Cal. Pittsburgh was selected by the AP and other selectors after a 8-0-1 season (again marred by a 0-0 tie with Fordham), while California (10-0-1 with a tie versus Washington) was selected by the contemporaneous Dunkel system as well as five other retroactive selectors.
- 1945 - Finished 10-0-0 (three selectors, including the National Championship Foundation (NCF), finished 3rd in the AP). The NCF is a retroactive selector, and while the NCAA doesn't recognize it as a selector for some reason after the AP poll came into being, it does use them as a recognized selector for pre-1936 championships. Alabama destroyed every team it played in 1945 and won the Rose Bowl 34-14 over USC. AP selected Heisman Trophy winner Doc Blanchard's Army (9-0-0) Cadets as national champ. Frankly, this Alabama squad is one of the the teams I wish Wayne Atcheson had selected for the eleventh national title (see Part I) rather than the 1941 team, as I think this team has a much better claim.
- 1950 - Finished 9-2-0 (chosen by Kirlin, finished 16th in the AP, 17th in UPI). This one is a head-scratcher. Alabama lost to Vanderbilt and Tennessee on the season and did not go to a bowl. Oklahoma (10-1) won both the AP and UPI titles (which were selected before the bowl games at this time) but lost to "Bear" Bryant's Kentucky Wildcats in the Sugar Bowl. Tennessee, which had beaten both Kentucky and Alabama, but had dropped a game to Mississippi State, wrapped up its 11-1 season with a win over Texas in the Cotton Bowl. Several selectors retroactively awarded the title to Tennessee.
- 1962 - Finished 10-1-0 (chosen by Montgomery, finished 5th in both polls). Alabama lost to Georgia Tech in the regular season, but blanked Oklahoma 17-0 in the Orange Bowl. Other claimants for 1962 include USC (11-0, AP and UPI champs) and Ole Miss (10-0, seven minor selectors).
- 1963 - Finished 9-2-0 (chosen by Koger, finished 8th in the AP, 9th in the UPI). Losing to both Florida and Auburn, this team defeated Ole Miss in the Sugar Bowl. Texas (11-0-0, defeating Navy in the Cotton Bowl) was the consensus champion.
- 1966 - Finished 11-0-0 (chosen by six selectors including NCF, finished 3rd in both polls). The 1966 season is a notorious one for 'Bama fans. Alabama had won both the '64 and '65 title, outscored its opponents 301-44 on the 1966 season, and throttled Nebraska 34-7 in the Sugar Bowl. In the meantime, #1 Notre Dame and #2 Michigan State, who were both 9-0 and faced off in late November, played each other to a 10-10 tie. Notre Dame head coach Ara Parseghian famously chose not to go for the win late in the game, electing to kick the field goal to tie the game. Notre Dame at this point in their history refused to go to any bowl game, and Michigan State was denied a bowl game by Big Ten rules, which didn't allow the same team to represent the conference in the Rose Bowl two years in a row and also didn't allow a conference team to go to any other bowl game. In addition, some feel that voters purposely denied Alabama the opportunity to win its third wire service (i.e. AP or UPI) national championship in a row, a feat that has still never been accomplished to this day, due to the state's dismal civil rights stance at the time, including its refusal to allow African-Americans to participate in football. Remember that Alabama governor George Wallace's "stand in the schoolhouse door" had taken place barely three years before. Regardless, this is the season that Alabama fans universally regard as one where the Tide was cheated out of a deserved title.
- 1974 - Finished 11-1-0 (chosen by the Washington Touchdown Club, finished 5th in the AP, 2nd in the UPI). The Tide completed the 1974 season undefeated, and like the year before, lost to Notre Dame in a bowl game, this time the Orange. Southern Cal (10-1-1, UPI, NFF, FWAA) lost to Arkansas in the season opener and tied California. Oklahoma (11-0-0, AP, NCF) ran the table, but was on NCAA probation and did not go to a bowl.
- 1975 - Finished 11-1-0 (chosen by three minor selectors, finished 3rd in both polls). The Tide lost the season opener to Missouri 20-7, then won out, including a 13-6 victory over Penn State in the Sugar Bowl. Oklahoma (11-1-0, including a shocking 23-3 loss at home to Kansas but a 28-27 win over Missouri) went into the Orange Bowl with Michigan ranked third in both polls. The top two teams (Ohio State and Texas A&M) lost their respective bowl games, and Oklahoma finished at #1 in both polls.
- 1977 - Finished 11-1-0 (chosen by two minor selectors, finished 2nd in both polls). Alabama's one loss on the season was to Nebraska in Lincoln 31-24 in the second game of the year. The Crimson Tide crushed the Buckeyes of Ohio State 35-6 in the Sugar Bowl. Notre Dame won both the AP and UPI titles, finishing 11-1 with a four-touchdown victory in the Cotton Bowl over Texas. Notre Dame's sole loss was a 20-13 decision to Ole Miss, whom Alabama had beaten 34-13 the week before. Are you getting the picture on why Alabama fans hate Notre Dame?
- 1980 - Finished 10-2-0 (chosen by two minor selectors, finished 6th in both polls). The Crimson Tide again was a two-time defending champion and ranked number one, but lost a 6-3 game to Mississippi State to break the team's 28-game winning streak. 'Bama lost 7-0 to Notre Dame two weeks later. Georgia (12-0-0), led by one of the greatest of all time, Herschel Walker, won the consensus national title.
- 1991 - Finished 11-1-0 (chosen by Annual Football Predictions, finished 5th in both polls). After losing in week two to the Florida Gators in a 35-0 blowout, the Tide started its longest unbeaten streak of all time, finishing 1991 with a victory over Colorado in the Blockbuster Bowl. Miami (12-0-0, AP) and Washington (12-0-0, UPI) both finished undefeated and split the title.
- 1994 - Finished 12-1-0 (chosen by Annual Football Predictions, finished 5th in AP, 4th in UPI). The third-ranked and undefeated Tide lost 24-23 to the sixth-ranked Florida Gators, in one of the greatest SEC Championship Games ever played. Nebraska (13-0-0) was the consensus champion, winning their first of two in a row.
Anyway, there you have it. Alabama has fourteen claimed national titles, thirteen of which stand on very solid footing. Additionally, the Crimson Tide could lay claim to up to thirteen other titles, and while a few of these are iffy, a fair case could easily be made for a few of them, particularly 1936, 1945, 1966, and 1977. I feel pretty certain that Alabama isn't going to back off of the 1941 title claim at this point, as it has memorialized that season in statue and stone, as well as numerous T-shirts, flags, bumper stickers, and whatnot. However, at least when some ignorant Barner makes a comment about "NASHUNAL CHAMPEANS, PAWWWWLLL," you can rest easy knowing that whatever the number may legitimately be, it is way more than Auburn has. Furthermore, the Tide isn't the only team that claims more titles than are broadly recognized. I'll leave you with this list of all teams with at least three recognized titles (to include Auburn).
Team Titles Recognized Titles Claimed Total (All Selectors)
Princeton 26 28 31
Yale 18 27 31
Alabama 13 14 27
Notre Dame 13 11 23
Michigan 11 11 21
USC 10 11 22
Pittsburgh 9 9 16
Harvard 8 8 19
Ohio State 7 7 20
Oklahoma 7 7 23
Minnesota 6 7 10
Pennsylvania 6 7 21
Army 5 3 11
Miami 5 5 10
Nebraska 5 5 14
California 4 5 5
Georgia Tech 4 4 7
Illinois 4 5 6
LSU 4 3 11
Michigan State 4 6 8
Penn State 4 2 15
Tennessee 4 6 14
Texas 4 4 13
Auburn 3 3 8
Cornell 3 5 5
Florida 3 3 5
Lafayette 3 3 3
Props to Cal and Cornell for straight up, unabashedly claiming all of theirs, deservedly or not.
*(Note: In fact, the Big Ten abolished the rule that kept Michigan State from repeating its trip to the Rose Bowl in 1972 and the rule that prevented them from accepting an invitation from another bowl prior to the 1975 season. Notre Dame did not accept a bowl invitation from 1924 to 1969. The Big Ten and Notre Dame had both, in the mid 1920s, made a decision to decline all bowl offers as a protest against the commercialization of college football. The Big Ten's ban lasted 26 years, Notre Dame's 45.)
Thursday, October 25, 2012
Alabama and the 14 National Championships, Part I
There are two popular memes about Alabama football fans that have pervaded over time. One is that Alabama fans are, by and large, "sidewalk fans," meaning that the majority of them have never gone to school at Alabama. The other is that Alabama claims a number of illegitimate national championships.
I have never understood the criticism of fans who didn't attend The University of Alabama. My parents both went to Alabama, as did a number of my aunts, uncles and cousins. I was an Alabama football fan from an early age, and even if I had gone to college somewhere else, I feel pretty certain that I would have always had a place in my heart for the Capstone. Besides, have all Notre Dame fans matriculated at South Bend? Does everyone who cheers for Boise State hail from Idaho? I suppose that the criticism is really one that is directed at any fan of a successful team - the so-called front-runners who come out of the woodwork when things are going well. But does 'Bama hold a monopoly on bandwagon fans? I doubt it.
Now the national championships. Alabama claims 14. Every other fan base in the country knows that's way too many, right? So what are the disputes and why does Alabama claim the ones that they do? If fourteen isn't the right number, what is?
As we all know, the NCAA does not name a championship team in FBS (formerly Division I-A) football. The "mythical national championship" or MNC for more than a century was more or less a beauty contest, based on teams that most likely never played each other. The BCS, for all its flaws, has largely eliminated the era of numerous national champions. By pairing the (more-or-less) consensus top two teams in the country in a championship game, other teams rarely jump ahead to claim a share of the title. But, in the days before every team with a record above .500 made it to a bowl game, this was not the case. Rather than crowning a champion, bowls were regarded by many as postseason exhibition games. Notre Dame famously refused to accept a bowl invitation for 45 years, from 1924 to 1969. The Associated Press (AP) and United Press International (UPI) both initially chose national champs before bowl games were even played (Alabama actually contributed to both services changing their systems).
According to the College Football Data Warehouse (CFDW) web site (www.cfbdatawarehouse.com), Alabama's football team has been named national champion 27 different seasons by one or more services. CFDW lists thirteen of those titles as "Recognized." The NCAA web site lists 12 Alabama championships, relying on nine or ten major sources. The AP, which started naming a champion in 1936, has awarded the Tide eight titles. The UPI/Coaches Poll, which dates back to 1950, has selected Alabama seven times. So, which number is correct? Let's start by examining the titles that Alabama claims, and why they did so.
This article, which initially appeared in the Birmingham News prior to the 2010 BCS National Championship Game between Alabama and Texas, says that the mid-1980s was when Alabama laid claim to, at the time, 11 national championships. Wayne Atcheson, who served as SID at Alabama from 1983-1987, added five titles to what was then accepted as six titles, at least according to the 1982 Alabama media guide, the last one published under Coach Paul W. "Bear" Bryant. Bryant's teams won each of those six titles, awarded by the AP and UPI, between 1958 and his retirement in 1982. Our journey begins with these six.
Okay, those seem fairly straightforward to me. While some misguided individuals may argue that the 1965 and 1973 championships are something less than legitimate due to the bowl losses, the wire service titles are recognized by everyone. Before we get to the five added titles, we might as well get three more out of the way that no one seriously disputes.
According to the previously-mentioned Birmingham News article, Taylor Watson - the curator of the Bryant Museum - said that the 1986 media guide was the first to mention the five additional titles. What you may not remember about 1986 is that Alabama began a two-season home-and-home series with Notre Dame that year. The Fighting Irish claim 11 national championships, but that number was ten at the time (the Irish later won the 1988 title). It's clear in hindsight that Wayne Atcheson went back over the Tide's history to find enough titles to edge out Notre Dame's ten. Hence, Alabama's number went to eleven national championships. So, what about those other five?
I have never understood the criticism of fans who didn't attend The University of Alabama. My parents both went to Alabama, as did a number of my aunts, uncles and cousins. I was an Alabama football fan from an early age, and even if I had gone to college somewhere else, I feel pretty certain that I would have always had a place in my heart for the Capstone. Besides, have all Notre Dame fans matriculated at South Bend? Does everyone who cheers for Boise State hail from Idaho? I suppose that the criticism is really one that is directed at any fan of a successful team - the so-called front-runners who come out of the woodwork when things are going well. But does 'Bama hold a monopoly on bandwagon fans? I doubt it.
Now the national championships. Alabama claims 14. Every other fan base in the country knows that's way too many, right? So what are the disputes and why does Alabama claim the ones that they do? If fourteen isn't the right number, what is?
As we all know, the NCAA does not name a championship team in FBS (formerly Division I-A) football. The "mythical national championship" or MNC for more than a century was more or less a beauty contest, based on teams that most likely never played each other. The BCS, for all its flaws, has largely eliminated the era of numerous national champions. By pairing the (more-or-less) consensus top two teams in the country in a championship game, other teams rarely jump ahead to claim a share of the title. But, in the days before every team with a record above .500 made it to a bowl game, this was not the case. Rather than crowning a champion, bowls were regarded by many as postseason exhibition games. Notre Dame famously refused to accept a bowl invitation for 45 years, from 1924 to 1969. The Associated Press (AP) and United Press International (UPI) both initially chose national champs before bowl games were even played (Alabama actually contributed to both services changing their systems).
According to the College Football Data Warehouse (CFDW) web site (www.cfbdatawarehouse.com), Alabama's football team has been named national champion 27 different seasons by one or more services. CFDW lists thirteen of those titles as "Recognized." The NCAA web site lists 12 Alabama championships, relying on nine or ten major sources. The AP, which started naming a champion in 1936, has awarded the Tide eight titles. The UPI/Coaches Poll, which dates back to 1950, has selected Alabama seven times. So, which number is correct? Let's start by examining the titles that Alabama claims, and why they did so.
This article, which initially appeared in the Birmingham News prior to the 2010 BCS National Championship Game between Alabama and Texas, says that the mid-1980s was when Alabama laid claim to, at the time, 11 national championships. Wayne Atcheson, who served as SID at Alabama from 1983-1987, added five titles to what was then accepted as six titles, at least according to the 1982 Alabama media guide, the last one published under Coach Paul W. "Bear" Bryant. Bryant's teams won each of those six titles, awarded by the AP and UPI, between 1958 and his retirement in 1982. Our journey begins with these six.
- 1961 - Finished 11-0-0. Awarded by AP and UPI and National Football Foundation (NFF). This one is as ironclad as they come. The Tide won every game, including the 1962 Sugar Bowl against Arkansas, although Ohio State (8-0-1; did not accept a bowl bid) was crowned by the Football Writers Association of America (FWAA). The Tide only allowed 25 total points by its opponents all season.
- 1964 - Finished 10-1-0. Awarded by AP and UPI. Alabama lost 21-17 against Texas in the Orange Bowl, although 'Bama fans swear that Joe Namath crossed the goal line to score the go-ahead touchdown. This game caused the AP to change its policy to award championships after the bowl games were played. Arkansas (11-0-0, FWAA, defeated Nebraska in the Cotton Bowl) and Notre Dame (9-1-0, awarded by NFF but not claimed by Notre Dame, who lost to USC in final regular season game) are recognized by the NCAA as co-champions.
- 1965 - Finished 9-1-1. Awarded by AP, FWAA and National Championship Foundation (NCF). The Tide lost their season opener to Georgia and tied Tennessee 7-7 at midseason, then destroyed Nebraska in the Orange Bowl. Michigan State (10-1-0) was awarded the title by the UPI, NFF and FWAA (tied with Alabama). The Spartans lost the Rose Bowl to UCLA.
- 1973 - Finished 11-1. Awarded by UPI. The Tide lost the Sugar Bowl 24-23 to Notre Dame, in what many hail as the greatest bowl game ever played. After this game, UPI changed their championship methodology to select after the bowl games were played. Notre Dame (11-0-0) was crowned by all the other major selectors.
- 1978 - Finished 11-1. Awarded by AP, FWAA, NFF, NCF. USC defeated 'Bama 24-14 in the third game of the season, and then lost to Arizona two weeks later. Alabama won the legendary 1979 Sugar Bowl over then-number one Penn State. The Trojans finished 12-1 and defeated Michigan in the Rose Bowl. USC was selected as champ by UPI and NCF (Tied with Alabama).
- 1979 - Finished 12-0. Consensus champion. Alabama defeated Lou Holtz's Arkansas team in the Sugar Bowl, but the closest contest was a 25-18 victory over Auburn in the Iron Bowl, which the Tide came from behind in the fourth quarter to win.
Okay, those seem fairly straightforward to me. While some misguided individuals may argue that the 1965 and 1973 championships are something less than legitimate due to the bowl losses, the wire service titles are recognized by everyone. Before we get to the five added titles, we might as well get three more out of the way that no one seriously disputes.
- 1992 - Finished 13-0-0. Consensus champion. 'Bama defeated top-ranked Miami in dominating fashion in the Sugar Bowl, breaking a 29-game winning streak by the defending national champs. The Tide also won the first-ever SEC Championship Game over Florida to make it to the title game.
- 2009 - Finished 14-0-0. BCS Champion. Alabama defeated Texas 37-21 after knocking the Longhorns' starting quarterback, Colt McCoy, out of the game early. The Crimson Tide defeated six ranked teams, including defending national champ and number one Florida, during the season.
- 2011 - Finished 12-1-0. BCS Champion. After losing at home in overtime to the number one team in the country, Alabama got a rematch with the LSU Tigers in the title game and blanked them 21-0.
According to the previously-mentioned Birmingham News article, Taylor Watson - the curator of the Bryant Museum - said that the 1986 media guide was the first to mention the five additional titles. What you may not remember about 1986 is that Alabama began a two-season home-and-home series with Notre Dame that year. The Fighting Irish claim 11 national championships, but that number was ten at the time (the Irish later won the 1988 title). It's clear in hindsight that Wayne Atcheson went back over the Tide's history to find enough titles to edge out Notre Dame's ten. Hence, Alabama's number went to eleven national championships. So, what about those other five?
- 1925 - Finished 10-0-0. Most disputes about Alabama's national titles start with the fact that the title selectors who are recognized today didn't exist in 1925, so while NCF, Helms, Houlgate and the College Football Researchers Association (CFRA), among others, all awarded the Tide the 1925 title, they did so retroactively. However, that doesn't mean that the Tide wasn't the best team in the country. In these early days when the Rose Bowl was the only bowl game in America, Alabama was the first team from the South to be invited to the game. The Rose Bowl attempted to match the top team in the East and with the top team in the West, and Alabama played the champion of the Pacific Coast Conference (the predecessor to today's Pac-12), Washington. The Tide won 20-19, and was greeted with congratulatory crowds in every Southern train station on the return trip. Furthermore, this newspaper article from the next day makes it clear that the game was regarded as the national championship at the time. The 1925 Dartmouth Indians (8-0-0) were also recognized (retroactively, I might add) as national champions by a couple of selectors, although they are not recognized by the NCAA.
- 1926 - Finished 9-0-1. Alabama again finished the regular season undefeated and was invited to the Rose Bowl to play Stanford. The game ended in a 7-7 tie, and as such, Alabama and Stanford shared the 1926 national championship awarded by Helms and NCF, while CFRA awarded the title solely to the Tide.
- 1930 - Finished 10-0-0. The Tide's third Rose Bowl trip ended in a 24-0 thrashing of Washington State, and the CFRA retroactively awarded them the title. Notre Dame, which refused the Rose Bowl invitation and finished 10-0-0, also shared the national title, being awarded by the NCF and Helms (also retroactive).
- 1934 - Finished 10-0-0. Again Alabama traveled to Pasadena to face Stanford and defeated the Cardinal 29-13. A number of selectors retroactively selected the Tide as national champs, although the three that the NCAA chooses to recognize (NCF, Helms, and CFRA) retroactively selected Big Ten champion Minnesota, who finished 8-0-0 (no bowl game).
- 1941 - Finished 9-2-0. This is the title that is the hardest to justify. By this time, the AP had begun selecting national champions, and Alabama finished 20th in the poll. In addition, the Tide didn't even win the SEC, losing to eventual champion Mississippi State (in their only SEC title to date) as well as Vanderbilt. While the Tide was selected as a national champion by the Houlgate system, it's hard to see why.
Sunday, October 21, 2012
SEC Football Week Eight: The Rundown
After eight weeks of football, we know a few things. We know Florida is back, and has a clear path to winning the SEC East. We know Alabama's defense is very good. We know that despite quarterback problems, LSU can run the ball and is good enough on defense to beat just about anyone. And we know that, with all other things being equal, turning the ball over multiple times is virtually guaranteed to lose football games for you. Let's start the Rundown!
1. Turnovers are Bad, Part I.
Texas A&M had the perfect setup to win Saturday against LSU: an early game, at home, with LSU looking ahead to a bye week and Alabama and coming off a tough victory over South Carolina. The Aggies looked unstoppable on the first drive and led 12-0 midway through the second quarter. Then they decided to be generous and give LSU an interception and a fumble to close out the half, both of which led to touchdowns for the Tigers. By the end of the game, A&M had turned the ball over five times, and despite out-gaining LSU by nearly 100 yards, having advantages in first downs, penalties and time of possession, and outplaying the Tigers for most of the game, LSU generated enough offense to escape College Station with a 24-19 win. Turnovers can make good teams look bad.
2. Turnovers are Bad, Part II.
If you only saw the 44-11 score of the Florida-South Carolina game, you might be tempted to think that the Gators had completely devastated the Gamecock defense, which had looked so good in previous weeks. In reality, the Gators had a 21-6 lead at halftime despite only gaining 29 yards of total offense. Carolina's Connor Shaw fumbled at the two yard line on the first play of the game from scrimmage, setting Florida up for their first TD. Later, Ace Sanders fumbled on a punt return deep in Carolina territory, giving the Gators another opportunity for a quick score. Finally, on the ensuing kickoff, Damiere Byrd coughed up the return, which was pick up and taken by Florida's Chris Johnson nearly to the goal line. Neither team gained over 200 yards for the entire game, but the Gamecocks' four turnovers put the game out of reach against the stingy Gator defense. Championship teams protect the football, which is one of the reasons Florida is likely going to Atlanta and South Carolina is not.
3. Coaching Hot Seat, Part I.
The last time Auburn started 1-6 was 1952. Dwight Eisenhower was elected to his first term as president, the U.S. was mired in a war in Korea, Elizabeth II began her 60-year reign as monarch in the United Kingdom, and the first hydrogen bomb was detonated. Auburn head coach Gene Chizik would not even be born for another nine years. I have to give Chizik credit. He has been a once-in-a-lifetime coach at Auburn, bringing them both their first national championship in over 50 years and their worst start in 60. It remains to be seen whether whoever is in charge at Auburn will allow the goodwill built from the former to outweigh the potentially devastating fallout from the latter, but it's obvious that Auburn's team, coaching staff and program are in complete disarray. In that 1952 season, Auburn finished winless in the SEC. After having lost to both Ole Miss and Vanderbilt in consecutive weeks, and with only Texas A&M, Georgia and Alabama remaining, the Tigers look very unlikely to win a conference game, go to a bowl game, or avoid a losing season. You know what other bad thing for Auburn happened 60 years ago? Nick Saban was born.
4. Coaching Hot Seat, Part II.
It wasn't bad enough for Derek Dooley that he was on crutches on the sideline following hip surgery and that Alabama was en route to a 44-13 demolishing of his team. Peyton Manning, Phil Fulmer and the rest of Tennessee's 1997 SEC Championship team were on hand to be honored at Saturday's game and to serve as a not-so-subtle reminder of how far the Volunteers have fallen. Tennessee's recent woes aren't quite as historical as Auburn's. After all, the Vols' 0-4 start in SEC play falls right in line with the last two seasons (0-6 to begin 2011, finished 1-7; 0-5 in 2010, finished 3-5). The problem is that every one of those seasons came under Dooley, who still hasn't beaten a ranked team in his tenure at Tennessee. You have to go back to 1910 to find a Tennessee coach with a worse winning percentage than Dooley, who is 14-18 in his three years at UT and 31-38 overall, and he has the worst record by far of anyone who lasted more than two years. The only reason that Dooley's status is still uncertain is that Tennessee's athletic department is in a hole financially - partially because they are still paying Phil Fulmer not to coach and partially because fans are staying away in droves. What is clear at this point is that Tennessee is closer to Missouri, Vanderbilt and Kentucky in the East than they are to Florida, Georgia and South Carolina.
5. The Good.
(2) Florida 44, (7) South Carolina 11
South Carolina's championship hopes came to a ignominious end as the Gators relied on their defense and special teams to propel them to their seventh win. Florida quarterback Jeff Driskel only had 93 yards passing, but threw for four touchdowns on the day.
(6) LSU 24, (18) Texas A&M 19
Stop me if you've heard this before: High-flying offense and Heisman-candidate quarterback with massive numbers finally plays a team with a decent defense and all-of-sudden the big numbers go away, the superhero is exposed as only human, and the team with the defense walks away with a win. What happened to Texas A&M's Johnny Manziel is the same old story that seems to surprise people year after year. Offensive numbers might win Heisman trophies, and I wouldn't be shocked if "Johnny Football" snags one in the coming years, but defense has, and always will, win championships, especially in the SEC.
(1) Alabama 44, Tennessee 13
AJ McCarron showed the Tennessee defense why stacking the line to stop the run is a losing proposition against Alabama this season as he threw for a career-high 306 yards and 4 touchdowns. McCarron, who has not thrown an interception all season, had an otherworldy 254.1 quarterback rating in the game and the Tide scored 30+ points in its seventh game in a row to start the season, which is a school record. Add that to the fact that Alabama leads the nation in total defense, scoring defense, run defense and pass efficiency defense, and you have a pretty lethal combination.
(12) Mississippi State 45, Middle Tennessee State 3
I know at least one person who thought this might be a close game (I'm looking at you, Matt), but State cruised to an easy victory on the arm of quarterback Tyler Russell, who threw for three touchdowns.
6. The Bad.
(11) Georgia 29, Kentucky 24
If South Carolina's blowout of Georgia and subsequent losses didn't tell you enough about the quality of this Bulldogs squad, the fact that they had to come from behind three times against a pitifully bad Kentucky team should.
7. The Ugly
Vanderbilt 17, Auburn 13
Before the season a lot of people gave Vandy coach James Franklin a chance to be competitive in the SEC East this year. While the Commodores (3-4) do still have a shot at a bowl game, Franklin did his best to give the game away to a historically terrible Auburn team. While Auburn had failed to drive the ball in the first quarter, two poor decisions by Franklin to go for it on fourth down in the second quarter led to ten points for the Tigers and kept them in the contest for far longer than their offensive production warranted. Then, when the game was on the line, Franklin seemed hesitant to give the ball to Zac Stacy, who became the 'Dores all-time leading rusher, until it was almost too late. Stacy, who had 169 yards on 27 carries and a touchdown on the day, appeared to be agitated as the Commodores kept throwing incomplete passes and not using very much time, then punting the ball back to Auburn, all while nursing a four-point lead. Franklin finally gave Stacy a chance, and while trying to put the team on his shoulders he ended up fumbling the ball and giving the Tigers one last chance to win. Against an average team, this would have been a loss.
8. Games to Watch in Week Nine
(2) Florida vs. (10) Georgia in Jacksonville
CBS and ESPN will do their best to play up this game as a contest for the SEC East title and that the outcome of this game determines who goes to Atlanta. Don't buy it. The winner of the East was determined Saturday when Florida (7-0) blew out South Carolina. Georgia (6-1) is soft, and the soft schedule has only served to make them look like a contender on paper. I expect a double-digit win for the Gators and a game that is over by halftime.
(11) Mississippi State at (1) Alabama
I give the Bulldogs (7-0) credit for their undefeated record, but the best team that they have played is probably Tennessee. The next three opponents for MSU are Alabama, Texas A&M, and LSU, so we'll get to see what this team is really made of, and frankly, I expect three losses. The biggest question for 'Bama (7-0) is whether or not they can focus on State with LSU coming in two weeks. So far, this team has been the most focused Alabama squad in my memory and has not played down to an opponent yet.
Tennessee at (13) South Carolina
I expect Carolina (6-2) to be down somewhat after having missed out on their goals for the season, and Tennessee (3-4) to be desperate to win. Really, that's the only way the Vols have a chance. Looks for the Gamecocks to make it three in a row over Tennessee.
Ole Miss at Arkansas
The Razorbacks (3-4) started the season as badly as any team could, but appeared to recover somewhat with wins over Auburn and Kentucky. Ole Miss (4-3) has already doubled their win total from last year and gave Alabama arguably their toughest game this season. While this game isn't for much more than pride, a shot at fourth place in the SEC West, and another step toward bowl eligibility, I think it will be intriguing to see whether Arkansas has truly recovered or whether the Rebels have overtaken them.
1. Turnovers are Bad, Part I.
Texas A&M had the perfect setup to win Saturday against LSU: an early game, at home, with LSU looking ahead to a bye week and Alabama and coming off a tough victory over South Carolina. The Aggies looked unstoppable on the first drive and led 12-0 midway through the second quarter. Then they decided to be generous and give LSU an interception and a fumble to close out the half, both of which led to touchdowns for the Tigers. By the end of the game, A&M had turned the ball over five times, and despite out-gaining LSU by nearly 100 yards, having advantages in first downs, penalties and time of possession, and outplaying the Tigers for most of the game, LSU generated enough offense to escape College Station with a 24-19 win. Turnovers can make good teams look bad.
2. Turnovers are Bad, Part II.
If you only saw the 44-11 score of the Florida-South Carolina game, you might be tempted to think that the Gators had completely devastated the Gamecock defense, which had looked so good in previous weeks. In reality, the Gators had a 21-6 lead at halftime despite only gaining 29 yards of total offense. Carolina's Connor Shaw fumbled at the two yard line on the first play of the game from scrimmage, setting Florida up for their first TD. Later, Ace Sanders fumbled on a punt return deep in Carolina territory, giving the Gators another opportunity for a quick score. Finally, on the ensuing kickoff, Damiere Byrd coughed up the return, which was pick up and taken by Florida's Chris Johnson nearly to the goal line. Neither team gained over 200 yards for the entire game, but the Gamecocks' four turnovers put the game out of reach against the stingy Gator defense. Championship teams protect the football, which is one of the reasons Florida is likely going to Atlanta and South Carolina is not.
3. Coaching Hot Seat, Part I.
The last time Auburn started 1-6 was 1952. Dwight Eisenhower was elected to his first term as president, the U.S. was mired in a war in Korea, Elizabeth II began her 60-year reign as monarch in the United Kingdom, and the first hydrogen bomb was detonated. Auburn head coach Gene Chizik would not even be born for another nine years. I have to give Chizik credit. He has been a once-in-a-lifetime coach at Auburn, bringing them both their first national championship in over 50 years and their worst start in 60. It remains to be seen whether whoever is in charge at Auburn will allow the goodwill built from the former to outweigh the potentially devastating fallout from the latter, but it's obvious that Auburn's team, coaching staff and program are in complete disarray. In that 1952 season, Auburn finished winless in the SEC. After having lost to both Ole Miss and Vanderbilt in consecutive weeks, and with only Texas A&M, Georgia and Alabama remaining, the Tigers look very unlikely to win a conference game, go to a bowl game, or avoid a losing season. You know what other bad thing for Auburn happened 60 years ago? Nick Saban was born.
4. Coaching Hot Seat, Part II.
It wasn't bad enough for Derek Dooley that he was on crutches on the sideline following hip surgery and that Alabama was en route to a 44-13 demolishing of his team. Peyton Manning, Phil Fulmer and the rest of Tennessee's 1997 SEC Championship team were on hand to be honored at Saturday's game and to serve as a not-so-subtle reminder of how far the Volunteers have fallen. Tennessee's recent woes aren't quite as historical as Auburn's. After all, the Vols' 0-4 start in SEC play falls right in line with the last two seasons (0-6 to begin 2011, finished 1-7; 0-5 in 2010, finished 3-5). The problem is that every one of those seasons came under Dooley, who still hasn't beaten a ranked team in his tenure at Tennessee. You have to go back to 1910 to find a Tennessee coach with a worse winning percentage than Dooley, who is 14-18 in his three years at UT and 31-38 overall, and he has the worst record by far of anyone who lasted more than two years. The only reason that Dooley's status is still uncertain is that Tennessee's athletic department is in a hole financially - partially because they are still paying Phil Fulmer not to coach and partially because fans are staying away in droves. What is clear at this point is that Tennessee is closer to Missouri, Vanderbilt and Kentucky in the East than they are to Florida, Georgia and South Carolina.
5. The Good.
(2) Florida 44, (7) South Carolina 11
South Carolina's championship hopes came to a ignominious end as the Gators relied on their defense and special teams to propel them to their seventh win. Florida quarterback Jeff Driskel only had 93 yards passing, but threw for four touchdowns on the day.
(6) LSU 24, (18) Texas A&M 19
Stop me if you've heard this before: High-flying offense and Heisman-candidate quarterback with massive numbers finally plays a team with a decent defense and all-of-sudden the big numbers go away, the superhero is exposed as only human, and the team with the defense walks away with a win. What happened to Texas A&M's Johnny Manziel is the same old story that seems to surprise people year after year. Offensive numbers might win Heisman trophies, and I wouldn't be shocked if "Johnny Football" snags one in the coming years, but defense has, and always will, win championships, especially in the SEC.
(1) Alabama 44, Tennessee 13
AJ McCarron showed the Tennessee defense why stacking the line to stop the run is a losing proposition against Alabama this season as he threw for a career-high 306 yards and 4 touchdowns. McCarron, who has not thrown an interception all season, had an otherworldy 254.1 quarterback rating in the game and the Tide scored 30+ points in its seventh game in a row to start the season, which is a school record. Add that to the fact that Alabama leads the nation in total defense, scoring defense, run defense and pass efficiency defense, and you have a pretty lethal combination.
(12) Mississippi State 45, Middle Tennessee State 3
I know at least one person who thought this might be a close game (I'm looking at you, Matt), but State cruised to an easy victory on the arm of quarterback Tyler Russell, who threw for three touchdowns.
6. The Bad.
(11) Georgia 29, Kentucky 24
If South Carolina's blowout of Georgia and subsequent losses didn't tell you enough about the quality of this Bulldogs squad, the fact that they had to come from behind three times against a pitifully bad Kentucky team should.
7. The Ugly
Vanderbilt 17, Auburn 13
Before the season a lot of people gave Vandy coach James Franklin a chance to be competitive in the SEC East this year. While the Commodores (3-4) do still have a shot at a bowl game, Franklin did his best to give the game away to a historically terrible Auburn team. While Auburn had failed to drive the ball in the first quarter, two poor decisions by Franklin to go for it on fourth down in the second quarter led to ten points for the Tigers and kept them in the contest for far longer than their offensive production warranted. Then, when the game was on the line, Franklin seemed hesitant to give the ball to Zac Stacy, who became the 'Dores all-time leading rusher, until it was almost too late. Stacy, who had 169 yards on 27 carries and a touchdown on the day, appeared to be agitated as the Commodores kept throwing incomplete passes and not using very much time, then punting the ball back to Auburn, all while nursing a four-point lead. Franklin finally gave Stacy a chance, and while trying to put the team on his shoulders he ended up fumbling the ball and giving the Tigers one last chance to win. Against an average team, this would have been a loss.
8. Games to Watch in Week Nine
(2) Florida vs. (10) Georgia in Jacksonville
CBS and ESPN will do their best to play up this game as a contest for the SEC East title and that the outcome of this game determines who goes to Atlanta. Don't buy it. The winner of the East was determined Saturday when Florida (7-0) blew out South Carolina. Georgia (6-1) is soft, and the soft schedule has only served to make them look like a contender on paper. I expect a double-digit win for the Gators and a game that is over by halftime.
(11) Mississippi State at (1) Alabama
I give the Bulldogs (7-0) credit for their undefeated record, but the best team that they have played is probably Tennessee. The next three opponents for MSU are Alabama, Texas A&M, and LSU, so we'll get to see what this team is really made of, and frankly, I expect three losses. The biggest question for 'Bama (7-0) is whether or not they can focus on State with LSU coming in two weeks. So far, this team has been the most focused Alabama squad in my memory and has not played down to an opponent yet.
Tennessee at (13) South Carolina
I expect Carolina (6-2) to be down somewhat after having missed out on their goals for the season, and Tennessee (3-4) to be desperate to win. Really, that's the only way the Vols have a chance. Looks for the Gamecocks to make it three in a row over Tennessee.
Ole Miss at Arkansas
The Razorbacks (3-4) started the season as badly as any team could, but appeared to recover somewhat with wins over Auburn and Kentucky. Ole Miss (4-3) has already doubled their win total from last year and gave Alabama arguably their toughest game this season. While this game isn't for much more than pride, a shot at fourth place in the SEC West, and another step toward bowl eligibility, I think it will be intriguing to see whether Arkansas has truly recovered or whether the Rebels have overtaken them.
Sunday, October 14, 2012
SEC Football Week Seven: The Rundown
We're already past the halfway point in the 2012 college football season. In the Southeastern Conference three undefeated teams remain, while another four have only one loss. All are still in the championship hunt. Even Kentucky is still mathematically bowl eligible, at least for one more week. This is the part of the season where attrition and the schedule separate the contenders from the pretenders. Let's start the Rundown!
1. All is Right with the World Again.
November 26, 1964. On that day, nearly half a century ago, Alabama defeated Auburn 21-14 and drew even with the Tigers in the all-time series with 14 wins and 14 losses. Since that date, the Crimson Tide has not had a losing record against any team in the Southeastern Conference, that is, until the Missouri Tigers officially joined the SEC on July 1, 2012. To be sure, Mizzou had only played Alabama three times historically, but they held a 1-2 edge over the Tide going into Saturday's 42-10 win at Faurot Field. So, mark October 13, 2012 as the date that Alabama righted the ship and re-established itself as the preeminent team in the nation's preeminent conference.
2. Missed Opportunity.
On the heels of last week's 35-7 blowout of Georgia, South Carolina looked like a world beater. Unfortunately for the Old Ball Coach, LSU is no Georgia. The Tigers ran all over the Gamecocks defense, outgained Carolina 406 yards to 211, and scored more points (23) than they have in any other SEC game so far this season. While Carolina is a good team, and a formidable opponent at home, great teams have to be able to win on the road in the SEC. Spurrier has still never beaten LSU since taking over at Columbia, SC, and the Gamecocks missed another opportunity to stake its claim as the best team in the conference. With Florida up next on the schedule, Carolina needs to recover quickly to have a chance to return to Atlanta in December.
3. Will Auburn Go Winless in the Conference?
No one expected Auburn to be a great team this year, but the schedule looked to be fairly negotiable before the season began. Now, the Tigers are 1-5 with their one victory coming in overtime against Louisiana-Monroe. The Tigers didn't look terrible against Ole Miss - the Rebels led 24-20 going into the fourth quarter - before the wheels came off. Auburn has been outscored 65-3 in the fourth quarter this season, which hints at depth and an inability to finish games. The Tigers have Vanderbilt in Nashville next week. While the Commodores won't be an easy out, if Auburn doesn't get a win there they are unlikely to win a game in the SEC and Gene Chizik's job is in serious jeopardy.
4. SEC West is Not Dead Yet.
The media storyline last week was that, with Florida's win over LSU and South Carolina's dominant performance over Georgia, the SEC East had jumped back ahead of the SEC West, which was basically just Alabama & everyone else. Granted, Auburn has been abysmal and Arkansas has recovered from freefall by beating the two worst teams in the league. However, Mississippi State has continued to win, and made a real statement last night against Tennessee. The Bulldogs are likely to be undefeated when they stroll into Tuscaloosa on October 27th. Texas A&M has one of the best young quarterbacks in college football, have won every game since a close opening loss to Florida, and just eliminated the last potential BCS-buster on the road in a shootout. And reports of LSU's demise have been greatly exaggerated. As long as the Tigers' defense stays healthy, they have a shot in every game they play. While three teams are still vying for the SEC East title, four teams control their destiny in the West. Let's wait a few more weeks before we pull the plug.
5. The Good
(9) LSU 23, (3) South Carolina 21
Freshman tailback Jeremy Hill led the Tigers with 124 yards on 17 carries and two touchdowns, wearing down Carolina's defense and bringing enough offense to give the Tigers a hard-fought win. Hill's 50-yard TD with 5:03 left in the fourth quarter broke the game open and ran Les Miles' record in night games at Tiger Stadium to 36-1.
(1) Alabama 42, Missouri 10
For the second time this year, Alabama faced a once-formidable offense without its first-team quarterback. Alabama has outscored those opponents 94-10. The Tide outgained Mizzou 533 yards to 129 and seemed to be challenged more by a driving rainstorm and a nearly 40-minute lightning delay than by the Tigers.
(4) Florida 31, Vanderbilt 17
This looked to be the prototypical "trap game" for Florida, falling as it did between the LSU victory last week and the pending South Carolina matchup. The Gators haven't lost to Vandy since 1988, and despite sleepwalking through the first half, quarterback/tailback Jeff Driskel's 177 yards and three touchdowns on the ground ensured that Florida came out on top.
(19) Mississippi State 41, Tennessee 31
The Bulldogs were 5-0 coming into the game with Tennessee, but two of those wins were against the two worst teams in the SEC (Auburn, Kentucky), two were against Sun Belt teams, and one was over an FCS school. Needless to say, Mississippi State had something to prove against the Volunteers. Tennessee hadn't beaten a ranked team in the Derek Dooley era, and were still looking for a signature win. At the end of the day, State is riding its best start since 1999 and Tennessee fell to 3-3 on the season with top-ranked Alabama coming to Knoxville next weekend.
(22) Texas A&M 59, (23) Louisiana Tech 57
The Aggies jumped out to a 34-7 lead, then had to hold on as the Bulldogs, who came into the game undefeated, came roaring back. Louisiana Tech had an opportunity to tie the game at 46-all in the fourth quarter, but failed on the two-point conversion, which eventually turned out to be the margin of victory for A&M. Johnny Manziel broke his two-week-old SEC total offense record with 576 total yards (181 rushing, 395 passing) and scored six touchdowns.
6. The Bad
Arkansas 49, Kentucky 7
How bad is Kentucky? Against an Arkansas team with wins over Auburn and Jacksonville State, the Wildcats allowed 49 points and 533 yards in a game that was called with 5:08 remaining in the third quarter due to lightning. At this point, the early win over Kent State appears to have been overachieving.
7. The Ugly
Ole Miss 41, Auburn 20
The Rebels jumped out to an early 14-0 lead and then gave Auburn arguably its best quarter of football all season, allowing the Tigers to drive to two second-quarter touchdowns and recover an onside kick that led to a field goal and a 17-14 lead. Hugh Freeze didn't learn from last week's bonehead decision to attempt a fourth-and-one conversion run from the shotgun in Ole Miss territory, and was just as successful this time. Congratulations to the Rebels for breaking an ugly 16-game SEC losing skid. While they are much improved over last season, this team will be lucky to win another one this year.
8. Games to Watch in Week Eight
(9) South Carolina at (3) Florida
The road doesn't get any easier for the Gamecocks as they travel to The Swamp to face the Gators. Florida seems to be improving every week, while Carolina has to win to get to Atlanta without outside help. The Gators have dropped the last two to Spurrier. I don't think the Gamecocks will make it three in a row.
(6) LSU at (20) Texas A&M
The SEC's most prolific offense at home against the vaunted LSU defense. Can "Johnny Football" go off on the Tigers' D? Can Zach Mettenberger and Jeremy Hill produce enough offense to keep up with A&M? I think that the early kickoff, the 12th Man, and the letdown after playing both Florida and South Carolina in previous weeks will impede LSU enough to give A&M the upset.
(1) Alabama at Tennessee
On paper, this looks like an easy win, but this storied rivalry has seen a number of upset wins over the years. The game is in Neyland Stadium and the Volunteers are desperate for a win. Tyler Bray and his receiving corps, led by Justin Hunter and Cordarelle Patterson, will be the toughest test for Alabama's defense so far this season. I expect the Tide to pull out a late victory, but as Lee Corso is fond of saying, it will be "closer than the experts think."
1. All is Right with the World Again.
November 26, 1964. On that day, nearly half a century ago, Alabama defeated Auburn 21-14 and drew even with the Tigers in the all-time series with 14 wins and 14 losses. Since that date, the Crimson Tide has not had a losing record against any team in the Southeastern Conference, that is, until the Missouri Tigers officially joined the SEC on July 1, 2012. To be sure, Mizzou had only played Alabama three times historically, but they held a 1-2 edge over the Tide going into Saturday's 42-10 win at Faurot Field. So, mark October 13, 2012 as the date that Alabama righted the ship and re-established itself as the preeminent team in the nation's preeminent conference.
2. Missed Opportunity.
On the heels of last week's 35-7 blowout of Georgia, South Carolina looked like a world beater. Unfortunately for the Old Ball Coach, LSU is no Georgia. The Tigers ran all over the Gamecocks defense, outgained Carolina 406 yards to 211, and scored more points (23) than they have in any other SEC game so far this season. While Carolina is a good team, and a formidable opponent at home, great teams have to be able to win on the road in the SEC. Spurrier has still never beaten LSU since taking over at Columbia, SC, and the Gamecocks missed another opportunity to stake its claim as the best team in the conference. With Florida up next on the schedule, Carolina needs to recover quickly to have a chance to return to Atlanta in December.
3. Will Auburn Go Winless in the Conference?
No one expected Auburn to be a great team this year, but the schedule looked to be fairly negotiable before the season began. Now, the Tigers are 1-5 with their one victory coming in overtime against Louisiana-Monroe. The Tigers didn't look terrible against Ole Miss - the Rebels led 24-20 going into the fourth quarter - before the wheels came off. Auburn has been outscored 65-3 in the fourth quarter this season, which hints at depth and an inability to finish games. The Tigers have Vanderbilt in Nashville next week. While the Commodores won't be an easy out, if Auburn doesn't get a win there they are unlikely to win a game in the SEC and Gene Chizik's job is in serious jeopardy.
4. SEC West is Not Dead Yet.
The media storyline last week was that, with Florida's win over LSU and South Carolina's dominant performance over Georgia, the SEC East had jumped back ahead of the SEC West, which was basically just Alabama & everyone else. Granted, Auburn has been abysmal and Arkansas has recovered from freefall by beating the two worst teams in the league. However, Mississippi State has continued to win, and made a real statement last night against Tennessee. The Bulldogs are likely to be undefeated when they stroll into Tuscaloosa on October 27th. Texas A&M has one of the best young quarterbacks in college football, have won every game since a close opening loss to Florida, and just eliminated the last potential BCS-buster on the road in a shootout. And reports of LSU's demise have been greatly exaggerated. As long as the Tigers' defense stays healthy, they have a shot in every game they play. While three teams are still vying for the SEC East title, four teams control their destiny in the West. Let's wait a few more weeks before we pull the plug.
5. The Good
(9) LSU 23, (3) South Carolina 21
Freshman tailback Jeremy Hill led the Tigers with 124 yards on 17 carries and two touchdowns, wearing down Carolina's defense and bringing enough offense to give the Tigers a hard-fought win. Hill's 50-yard TD with 5:03 left in the fourth quarter broke the game open and ran Les Miles' record in night games at Tiger Stadium to 36-1.
(1) Alabama 42, Missouri 10
For the second time this year, Alabama faced a once-formidable offense without its first-team quarterback. Alabama has outscored those opponents 94-10. The Tide outgained Mizzou 533 yards to 129 and seemed to be challenged more by a driving rainstorm and a nearly 40-minute lightning delay than by the Tigers.
(4) Florida 31, Vanderbilt 17
This looked to be the prototypical "trap game" for Florida, falling as it did between the LSU victory last week and the pending South Carolina matchup. The Gators haven't lost to Vandy since 1988, and despite sleepwalking through the first half, quarterback/tailback Jeff Driskel's 177 yards and three touchdowns on the ground ensured that Florida came out on top.
(19) Mississippi State 41, Tennessee 31
The Bulldogs were 5-0 coming into the game with Tennessee, but two of those wins were against the two worst teams in the SEC (Auburn, Kentucky), two were against Sun Belt teams, and one was over an FCS school. Needless to say, Mississippi State had something to prove against the Volunteers. Tennessee hadn't beaten a ranked team in the Derek Dooley era, and were still looking for a signature win. At the end of the day, State is riding its best start since 1999 and Tennessee fell to 3-3 on the season with top-ranked Alabama coming to Knoxville next weekend.
(22) Texas A&M 59, (23) Louisiana Tech 57
The Aggies jumped out to a 34-7 lead, then had to hold on as the Bulldogs, who came into the game undefeated, came roaring back. Louisiana Tech had an opportunity to tie the game at 46-all in the fourth quarter, but failed on the two-point conversion, which eventually turned out to be the margin of victory for A&M. Johnny Manziel broke his two-week-old SEC total offense record with 576 total yards (181 rushing, 395 passing) and scored six touchdowns.
6. The Bad
Arkansas 49, Kentucky 7
How bad is Kentucky? Against an Arkansas team with wins over Auburn and Jacksonville State, the Wildcats allowed 49 points and 533 yards in a game that was called with 5:08 remaining in the third quarter due to lightning. At this point, the early win over Kent State appears to have been overachieving.
7. The Ugly
Ole Miss 41, Auburn 20
The Rebels jumped out to an early 14-0 lead and then gave Auburn arguably its best quarter of football all season, allowing the Tigers to drive to two second-quarter touchdowns and recover an onside kick that led to a field goal and a 17-14 lead. Hugh Freeze didn't learn from last week's bonehead decision to attempt a fourth-and-one conversion run from the shotgun in Ole Miss territory, and was just as successful this time. Congratulations to the Rebels for breaking an ugly 16-game SEC losing skid. While they are much improved over last season, this team will be lucky to win another one this year.
8. Games to Watch in Week Eight
(9) South Carolina at (3) Florida
The road doesn't get any easier for the Gamecocks as they travel to The Swamp to face the Gators. Florida seems to be improving every week, while Carolina has to win to get to Atlanta without outside help. The Gators have dropped the last two to Spurrier. I don't think the Gamecocks will make it three in a row.
(6) LSU at (20) Texas A&M
The SEC's most prolific offense at home against the vaunted LSU defense. Can "Johnny Football" go off on the Tigers' D? Can Zach Mettenberger and Jeremy Hill produce enough offense to keep up with A&M? I think that the early kickoff, the 12th Man, and the letdown after playing both Florida and South Carolina in previous weeks will impede LSU enough to give A&M the upset.
(1) Alabama at Tennessee
On paper, this looks like an easy win, but this storied rivalry has seen a number of upset wins over the years. The game is in Neyland Stadium and the Volunteers are desperate for a win. Tyler Bray and his receiving corps, led by Justin Hunter and Cordarelle Patterson, will be the toughest test for Alabama's defense so far this season. I expect the Tide to pull out a late victory, but as Lee Corso is fond of saying, it will be "closer than the experts think."
Saturday, October 06, 2012
SEC Football Week Six: The Rundown
With the bye week for Alabama, I was able to watch at least a little bit of every SEC game as well as parts of other contests. Even without the Tide playing, it was a strong weekend of college football. At the end of the day, we are down to four undefeated teams in the Southeastern Conference, and at least two of them are surprise contenders. Let's start the rundown!
1. The King is Dead/Long Live the King.
One of the easiest media picks in the offseason was that LSU and Alabama would be back atop the SEC and that LSU would repeat as SEC champion with most of their defense returning and a brand-new (better) quarterback. Well, (3) LSU's defense is still very good, but the offense is downright lethargic. The Tigers only converted one third down in Saturday's 14-6 loss to (10) Florida and garnered only 200 yards of offense. Once the Gators scored their second touchdown, no one except die hard LSU fans thought that the Tigers had any chance of driving the field to win. Florida didn't necessarily light up the scoreboard, but they have consistently played good defense and adjusted well at halftime against their opponents. The Gators have established themselves again at the top of the SEC East. Whether they can beat both South Carolina and Georgia is still a question, but for now the Gators are back on top.
2. South Carolina is a national championship contender/Georgia - not so much.
Count me as one of those who was never sold on the Georgia Bulldogs. The other easy media pick was that the Bulldogs had an easy schedule that didn't require them to play Alabama, LSU or Arkansas, just like last year, and that they would return to the SEC Championship Game. Unfortunately for Mark Richt, you actually have to play the games to win them, and that schedule looks a lot tougher today than it did in July. Sixth-ranked South Carolina's offense drove the field immediately on the Bulldogs, the crowd was as loud and raucous as you could imagine for a primetime game between two top-ten teams with ESPN GameDay on site, and by the end of the first quarter, the game was over. The Gamecocks dominated on both sides of the ball, and made (5) Georgia look like an also-ran.
3. Arkansas stops the bleeding/Auburn opens another vein.
No team in the country had a worse September than the Arkansas Razorbacks. After winning their first game against FCS opponent Jacksonville State, the 'Backs went on a catastrophic slide, one so bad it's difficult to name the low point. Many, including me, have accused the team of giving up when the chips were down. They needed a win against Auburn badly. Unfortunately for the Tigers, they needed this win too. September wasn't quite as bad as Arkansas' only in the sense that Auburn fans didn't have high expectations to begin with. Tiger fans could console themselves in the bye week that they had a chance to win against the second-ranked LSU Tigers and might have looked slightly better on offense. Also, they had one of the worst defenses in the country coming to their house to improve against. At the end of the day, the Auburn offense was in shambles, playing three quarterbacks who were sacked eight times and turning the ball over five times. Arkansas saves the season, at least for this week, with a 24-7 win.
4. Mississippi State is quietly 5-0 for the first time since 1999.
While the Bulldogs have admittedly played a light schedule, they have done what they needed to do every week and have taken care of business. With the 27-14 win over Kentucky, Mississippi State stands alone with Alabama atop the SEC West. I'm not ready to put Bully up there with Alabama, Carolina and Florida, but after next week's match-up with Tennessee I think we'll have a much better idea of how good this team is. The great thing about college football is that any week you can have a NC State over Florida State, a Vandy over Missouri, or an Iowa State over TCU. Don't count the Bulldogs out yet.
5. The Good.
(10) Florida 14, (4) LSU 6
Mike Gillislee carried the rock 34 times against LSU for 146 yards and two touchdowns. Early yardage was difficult to come by, but LSU's inability to drive the ball consistently eventually wore down the defense. The team that rushes for the most yardage in this game has won every year since Les Miles took over at LSU. Florida establishes itself as a strong contender in the East while LSU realistically has to win out to make it back to the SEC Championship Game.
(6) South Carolina 35, (5) Georgia 7
Georgia's star rushing duo of Gurley and Marshall were the story entering the game, but Marcus Lattimore rushed for 104 yards and USC nearly doubled Georgia's offensive output as the Bulldogs were completely dominated from the outset. South Carolina at Florida on October 20 looks to be epic, but both teams have a few hurdles to top before they get there.
(20) Mississippi State 27, Kentucky 14
State dominates the hapless Wildcats in a game that wasn't as close as the score indicated. Bulldog quarterback Tyler Russell is improving every week, but the first real test approaches.
Texas A&M 30, Ole Miss 27
Both teams had a chance to win this one, and it was back and forth the whole game. Ole Miss coach Hugh freeze made a bonehead decision to go for a fourth and one deep in their own territory late in the game and didn't make it, giving A&M an opportunity for the go-ahead score. The Aggies, after falling to Florida early, are 4-1 and gaining confidence. Kevin Sumlin has to be an early candidate for SEC Coach of the Year.
6. The Bad
Arkansas 24, Auburn 7
Yeah, the Razorbacks won, and they needed it. But let's not kid ourselves. Both of these teams are hilariously bad.
7. The Ugly
Vanderbilt 19, Missouri 14
Missouri signal caller James Franklin left the game early with a knee injury. Vandy didn't even get a first down until near halftime. The Tigers missed a PAT and gave up a safety on a bobbled punt attempt. Props to the Commodores for the win, but this one was hard to watch.
8. Games to Watch in Week Seven
South Carolina at LSU
The Gamecocks played their best game of the year (maybe one of their best ever) against Georgia. Can they avoid the letdown on the road in Baton Rouge? Will LSU rebound from the tough loss at Florida? I think USC is a better team, but night games at Tiger Stadium are notoriously tough. I think it's easier for defenses to recover from the big game, and LSU has shown me nothing good on offense. I'm picking Cocky to win.
Auburn at Ole Miss
No game for Auburn is a gimme, and Ole Miss is looking better every week. I think the Rebels will pick up their first SEC win since 2010.
Tennessee at Mississippi State
This is an intriguing game. Tennessee head coach Derek Dooley cannot lose this game if he wants to stay around another year. State is probably good enough to pull off the win, but I am leaning toward the Vols due to the desperation factor.
Alabama at Missouri
Alabama's second road test of the season doesn't appear to be much of a challenge, especially since Vanderbilt just won in Columbia. However, Missouri happens to be the only SEC team against which the Crimson Tide has a losing record (1-2 in three games in the sixties and seventies) and it's important to go ahead and take care of that. Expect the Tide to roll.
Texas A&M at Louisiana Tech
This game was originally scheduled for the first weekend of the season, but was postponed due to Hurricane Isaac. In the meantime, La Tech is 5-0 and sporting wins against Conference-USA (Houston, Rice), the B1G (Illinois), the ACC (Virginia) and the Mountain West (UNLV). The Bulldogs will start getting serious attention if they beat the Aggies. I suspect the Cinderella season comes to an end at the hands of "Johnny Football."
1. The King is Dead/Long Live the King.
One of the easiest media picks in the offseason was that LSU and Alabama would be back atop the SEC and that LSU would repeat as SEC champion with most of their defense returning and a brand-new (better) quarterback. Well, (3) LSU's defense is still very good, but the offense is downright lethargic. The Tigers only converted one third down in Saturday's 14-6 loss to (10) Florida and garnered only 200 yards of offense. Once the Gators scored their second touchdown, no one except die hard LSU fans thought that the Tigers had any chance of driving the field to win. Florida didn't necessarily light up the scoreboard, but they have consistently played good defense and adjusted well at halftime against their opponents. The Gators have established themselves again at the top of the SEC East. Whether they can beat both South Carolina and Georgia is still a question, but for now the Gators are back on top.
2. South Carolina is a national championship contender/Georgia - not so much.
Count me as one of those who was never sold on the Georgia Bulldogs. The other easy media pick was that the Bulldogs had an easy schedule that didn't require them to play Alabama, LSU or Arkansas, just like last year, and that they would return to the SEC Championship Game. Unfortunately for Mark Richt, you actually have to play the games to win them, and that schedule looks a lot tougher today than it did in July. Sixth-ranked South Carolina's offense drove the field immediately on the Bulldogs, the crowd was as loud and raucous as you could imagine for a primetime game between two top-ten teams with ESPN GameDay on site, and by the end of the first quarter, the game was over. The Gamecocks dominated on both sides of the ball, and made (5) Georgia look like an also-ran.
3. Arkansas stops the bleeding/Auburn opens another vein.
No team in the country had a worse September than the Arkansas Razorbacks. After winning their first game against FCS opponent Jacksonville State, the 'Backs went on a catastrophic slide, one so bad it's difficult to name the low point. Many, including me, have accused the team of giving up when the chips were down. They needed a win against Auburn badly. Unfortunately for the Tigers, they needed this win too. September wasn't quite as bad as Arkansas' only in the sense that Auburn fans didn't have high expectations to begin with. Tiger fans could console themselves in the bye week that they had a chance to win against the second-ranked LSU Tigers and might have looked slightly better on offense. Also, they had one of the worst defenses in the country coming to their house to improve against. At the end of the day, the Auburn offense was in shambles, playing three quarterbacks who were sacked eight times and turning the ball over five times. Arkansas saves the season, at least for this week, with a 24-7 win.
4. Mississippi State is quietly 5-0 for the first time since 1999.
While the Bulldogs have admittedly played a light schedule, they have done what they needed to do every week and have taken care of business. With the 27-14 win over Kentucky, Mississippi State stands alone with Alabama atop the SEC West. I'm not ready to put Bully up there with Alabama, Carolina and Florida, but after next week's match-up with Tennessee I think we'll have a much better idea of how good this team is. The great thing about college football is that any week you can have a NC State over Florida State, a Vandy over Missouri, or an Iowa State over TCU. Don't count the Bulldogs out yet.
5. The Good.
(10) Florida 14, (4) LSU 6
Mike Gillislee carried the rock 34 times against LSU for 146 yards and two touchdowns. Early yardage was difficult to come by, but LSU's inability to drive the ball consistently eventually wore down the defense. The team that rushes for the most yardage in this game has won every year since Les Miles took over at LSU. Florida establishes itself as a strong contender in the East while LSU realistically has to win out to make it back to the SEC Championship Game.
(6) South Carolina 35, (5) Georgia 7
Georgia's star rushing duo of Gurley and Marshall were the story entering the game, but Marcus Lattimore rushed for 104 yards and USC nearly doubled Georgia's offensive output as the Bulldogs were completely dominated from the outset. South Carolina at Florida on October 20 looks to be epic, but both teams have a few hurdles to top before they get there.
(20) Mississippi State 27, Kentucky 14
State dominates the hapless Wildcats in a game that wasn't as close as the score indicated. Bulldog quarterback Tyler Russell is improving every week, but the first real test approaches.
Texas A&M 30, Ole Miss 27
Both teams had a chance to win this one, and it was back and forth the whole game. Ole Miss coach Hugh freeze made a bonehead decision to go for a fourth and one deep in their own territory late in the game and didn't make it, giving A&M an opportunity for the go-ahead score. The Aggies, after falling to Florida early, are 4-1 and gaining confidence. Kevin Sumlin has to be an early candidate for SEC Coach of the Year.
6. The Bad
Arkansas 24, Auburn 7
Yeah, the Razorbacks won, and they needed it. But let's not kid ourselves. Both of these teams are hilariously bad.
7. The Ugly
Vanderbilt 19, Missouri 14
Missouri signal caller James Franklin left the game early with a knee injury. Vandy didn't even get a first down until near halftime. The Tigers missed a PAT and gave up a safety on a bobbled punt attempt. Props to the Commodores for the win, but this one was hard to watch.
8. Games to Watch in Week Seven
South Carolina at LSU
The Gamecocks played their best game of the year (maybe one of their best ever) against Georgia. Can they avoid the letdown on the road in Baton Rouge? Will LSU rebound from the tough loss at Florida? I think USC is a better team, but night games at Tiger Stadium are notoriously tough. I think it's easier for defenses to recover from the big game, and LSU has shown me nothing good on offense. I'm picking Cocky to win.
Auburn at Ole Miss
No game for Auburn is a gimme, and Ole Miss is looking better every week. I think the Rebels will pick up their first SEC win since 2010.
Tennessee at Mississippi State
This is an intriguing game. Tennessee head coach Derek Dooley cannot lose this game if he wants to stay around another year. State is probably good enough to pull off the win, but I am leaning toward the Vols due to the desperation factor.
Alabama at Missouri
Alabama's second road test of the season doesn't appear to be much of a challenge, especially since Vanderbilt just won in Columbia. However, Missouri happens to be the only SEC team against which the Crimson Tide has a losing record (1-2 in three games in the sixties and seventies) and it's important to go ahead and take care of that. Expect the Tide to roll.
Texas A&M at Louisiana Tech
This game was originally scheduled for the first weekend of the season, but was postponed due to Hurricane Isaac. In the meantime, La Tech is 5-0 and sporting wins against Conference-USA (Houston, Rice), the B1G (Illinois), the ACC (Virginia) and the Mountain West (UNLV). The Bulldogs will start getting serious attention if they beat the Aggies. I suspect the Cinderella season comes to an end at the hands of "Johnny Football."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
